Stiff Arm

He bounced it as he ran past the umpire. The tv vision didn't show that. From where he bounced to where he kicked it could arguably been too far, but he definitely bounced it

💯 Claz Not a shadow of doubt

Not sure where to put this, or if it's been posted before, but there's a few to look forward to (until the AFL shafts us again with more targeted rule changes) https://www.melbournefc.com.au/news/1753057/melbourne-academy-players-to-watch

If, if we get Kalani White and Toby Sinnema this year without a 1st rounder, is that enough? Are we really in the hunt for PA's Bergman or GWS' Brown?

You are aware we have no 1st rounder this year? What might have been pick 5 is now Essendon's to use. Or are you talking about 2026 and 2027? My money is on Taylor/Lamb trading those picks out as well.

Huh??? Gerard Healy has a particular dislike for Melb, has for years. Supposedly stems back to how he perceives he was treated by the club when he left, but I'm not sure about that. Even when we win he finds ways to make snide remarks, subtle backhanders that are wrapped up in an attempt at compliments. I like him when it's not us playing, he's a good commentator with excellent insight. Having said that, would rather him work a Melb game than Dermie, BT or screaming Brayshaw any day of the week

IMO it would be good to leave Jeffo in the side for the rest of the year. Then we'll have an answer about his ability at AFL level once and for all. He was very, very quiet today, at half time I wasnt sure he was playing 😳

Dominating VFL???

Then he won't like the ball landing on his head from 200m up

Collingwood's forward line is the antithesis of ours. They're fast, open, clean and accurate [censored] me up the wall

Bobby Hill: 0 disposal Darcy Moore: 2 disposal

Jeez, Nick Faicos can read the play well under zero pressure. Sublime

Collingwood double the Saints free kick count Josh Daicos just threw it out of a tackle inside saints f50. Play on! It must be easy being a Pies supporter when you know it's always stacked in your favour And AFL bosses love it

In our long bomb forward line he would be hopeless. With the pies exceptional delivery he looks a million dollars

Agree, Windsor is having a poor season, which could be contributed somewhat to an interrupted preseason. Are we expecting too much from a second year player whose just turned 20? To me, Windsor's kicking last year looked a strength, his kicks to advantage were excellent and he was one of the few regularly lowering his eyes i50. IMO the comparisons to Jayden Hunt are incorrect. His year reflects second year blues (for want of a better term) from a guy in a team that is bottom 6 and all over the shop. Put him in a top 4 team and we'd all be saying why did we pick Caddy instead of him? The real crime is that Logan Morris, Joel Freijar and Darcy Wilson were not on our radar enough. We traded 14, 27 and 35 for pick 11 to get the Kolt. We could've got all three. Coulda, shoulda, woulda Hmmmmm 🤔

West Coast currently doing 'a Melbourne'

Max MUST give off every time i50. Every-fricking-time!

Choco Williams has to go at seasons end. Has to.

No, we're playing the bugle wearing a blazer

Season done. Play the kids Adams for May/Lever Jeffo for Petty, keep Roo in, Sesto, Kolt, Laurie, Mentha, Johnson need games

Yeah, season gone Play the kids: JvR, Jeffo, Lindsay, Kolt, maybe Seston, and Mentha I'd even give Adams a run

Kossie is out of sorts. 2 touches in 2nd half. Must have been effected by that hit

Steven May is a dumb, dumb bloke