one_demon

Season is done. No need to rush Lever back in.

TMac. Wow.

We desperately need a key forward because TMac is now getting the best defender and he can't cope.

Do we have any chance of getting him? Jones, Lewis and one other should free up enough salary cap space.

We could be damned either way. If we stay with the chaos game plan, it probably won't win us a premiership. If we change to controlled ball movement, we've given everyone a head start.

I wonder whether the skills of the players are actually better than what's been on display this year. It's just the game style causes the players to rush their disposals. Is we slowed our ball movement down and played with a bit more composure we may be able to hit our targets more often.

Yes. Our disposals end up being chaotic as well

Spot on

Spot on

Surely Jones can't go around next year. The only position he can play is inside mid, and that's locked out. We've been trying to hide him all year.

Because we've played too many under-done players before

Don't pick players returning from injury at least until after the bye

Totally agree. I'm desperately hoping for a club review. Something ain't right.

Goodwin says Lever, May, Hannan, Salem, Hibberd, Weideman, JKH, Kolodjashnii and ANB are all available next week

Sums up both players perfectly

You're welcome to start your own thread about OMac

OMac wasn't one of the choices

Not really. Often the team in that situation becomes determined to remedy the situation.

Once May, Lever and Hibberd return some defenders may get squeezed out. If it came to a choice between Frost or Hore, which would you choose?

To me, this is just common sense. Nothing can be gained by playing Lewis especially if he takes the place of a younger player like Petty.

Giants' poor MCG record is at the forefront of their players' minds this week. They will win.

One advantage we have in preparation for next year is that we can send players in for surgery early. So a lot more of our players will cherry ripe for the start of the season.

There's always another six decades

I have similar concerns with May. We gave up pick six for a player who may only play for three to five years.