one_demon

And you're not?

You can't assess performance on stats alone. Stats don't tell the full story

Ha ha. Good one.

You picked out two stats. The Voss stat is irrelevant considering he's coached Carlton for 18 months. We were awful. There's no way we're winning it playing like that

As a forward. Just because he's played forward at VFL level for eight weeks doesn't mean he's any good in that position. Also, AFL level is big step up from VFL

Correct

Very true. Some people when they don't like a commentator saying negative things about their club not matter how legitimate, they'll go after the commentator.

https://www.foxsports.com.au/afl/afl-2023-melbourne-demons-narrm-football-club-premiership/news-story/aec29731dedb4f21a7c49c46e33d078b

There's no way Smith is being picked as a forward. Some of these suggestions are laughable

Good posting

You were always going to criticize no matter what he or she said

Yes. You can't just look at the margin. We were well beaten in the first half and in the last quarter we couldn't move the ball

The TSL has been struggling for quite some time. Don't know why the AFL is happy to see it die

Yeah I hope they don't go with that jumper or at least modernise it. I don't mind the colours either and no-one wears green

That doesn't mean he isn't a defensive coach. Point for doesn't give you a complete picture. It's one statistic.

Very defensive coach. Teams aren't playing like that anymore so it will be interesting to see what game plan he come up with

Better to be a realist

Great point

It's childish. Just ignore it.

Yze to St Kilda and Ratten to Melbourne

Probably won't do much forward but handy because he can play in defence and ruck as well

Forward line problems solved!

Does he get selected ahead of JVR next year?

Takes Weideman's role of being in and out of the team

Takes Weideman's role of being in and out of the team