Fanatique Demon

A W I S E assessment.

6. Oliver 5. Langdon 4. Petracca 3. Brayshaw 2. May 1. Viney

Thanks Joeboy. I look forward to this each week.

True! ?

I really don't see the point in posting articles most of us can't access. At least not without a summary of contents.

I thought VDB... offered much grunt

6. Petracca 5. Oliver 4. Brayshaw 3. Langdon 2. Lever 1. Weideman

Thanks for posting that, Blind_turn. Interesting. And I like the way Mitchel asks Worpel what he should do rather than just telling him. It makes me wonder whether our player reviews are as professionally conducted.

Can't access it.

Happy to be wrong about his Rising Star chances. I knew it would come but I didn't think it would have been for last week's game. Well done Jacko!

Seriously... it was another step forward for Jackson, but he has a long way to go to be a Rising Star of the calibre of other nominees. They don't give the award on potential. We all want him to be great, but he's not. Not yet, anyway. Same goes for Kozzie. Three minutes of highlights. Looong way to go.

He certainly will be! Just not yet.

ANB : Alas, No Better

Jones : sadly, time's up Harmes : much better today

There's a lot of premature love (and hope) for Jackson! 6. Oliver 5. Petracca 4. May 3. Viney 2. Salem 1. Lever

Thanks, Mr Nails.

Werridee might have to review his profile. His favourite players include TMac, Oliver and Jones. None of them fits into his team.

Our team is very different this year. But if Adelaide is going to win a game in 2020, it will be against us.

I was looking forward to Joeboy's assessment.

Giving anyone votes in this game only devalues the votes EARNED by others in REAL games.

6. Viney 5. May 4. Melksham 3. Oliver 2. Petracca 1. Lever

Good that Jones is back. But I fear he will be caught holding the ball. He likes to force the stoppage by holding it in and under, and he doesn't try to dispose of it. The rule has a new interpretation and if he doesn't adapt, he'll give away 2 or 3 free kicks.

6. Gawn 5. Petracca 4. Viney ---------------- 3. Weideman 2. Oliver 1. Langdon

Someone gave Picket a vote for a six possession game(at 66% efficiency). I like him too, but are we voting for best, or favourites?

Easy to see favourites here. Kozzy versus Melksham. Too much praise for the first - yes, he's exciting to watch and he kicked two goals. But only 6 disposals at 66% efficiency. He's got talent all right and one day he might rival Farmer. But not now. Not enough recognition of the latter. Melksham played his role. Nine disposals at 88% efficiency and five marks and a goal. Credit where it's due.