58er

"Best 2 Available players "can be subjective " Polly and DEESP. I have no doubt that Bowey and Laurie were the " best 2 available for Melbournes needs" and that's all I am worried about. If the best player generally considered at 21 was a ruck and 22 was a half Back flanker MOST fans would be livid if our 2 started starring fir later picks at other Clubs knowing we needed outside runners for our midfield and forward line. And the list at 34 changes at every no prior with different selections so a quick reaffirmation of your selection With the "voters' is Quite within order. Melb has 3 mins ( I think might be more) to place our selection so there is no hurry. It's not indecision but ticking your box carefully. Thank heavens dime D/L ers are nit allowed any where near JT and his team in the Box!!!

BRFE You do realise that the Cats Traded up Deliberately to pick 20 and got in first before us for Holmes That's why Holmes DID NOT appear the be in the picture ! He wasn't he was gone Pick 20 GFC!!!!

Another Quarter GLASS full Open the eyes that is a very good summary of where we sit. Don't be surprised if most of that falls into place.

Great photo BBB is a bit small!!!

Damo It's not 4 months PS training its strictly Jan for 4 years and above players plus any private work Burgo gave each player. They had to have 6 weeks whatever off as Annusl leave also since late September. Late year remember due to Covid!! You just cant always pick the best player in a position it doesnt always give team balance and Practice Or pre Season matches are also for Experiments!

Nascent We had already done our trading up to get 2 first round selections prior to the draft!!! You have forgotten. vety good selections and happened the way any supporter could be pleased about. 2 best kicksxand 2 best decision makers Thank you very much and Rosman the Big Smokey with all the ability and run in his tank! Ready made fir a wing ( and cameos on the forward line and no doubt at half back!) Well done JT and team. Let the tougher stuff reveal the beauty in these decisions.

But you are not funny OD. Boring and repetitive!! Quarter glass full stuff.

Other than the fact that Fraser is doing everything right to gain the wing position opposite Langers in Round1.

Read the Track reports OD! Your Wooden spoon referral is past humour! Good to say nothing as we were taught in the Old Days it's best to not say Anything if you don't have aany thing good to say at all !!!

Irrespective of BB we need a fit and firing Tmac on the Forward line, If needed in defence, and of course in the ruck and for about 2 mins a quarter perhaps on the wing! Absolutely Crucial to our list that Tom regains 2018 form In whatever position or category he plays. Top 4 if Tom goes well and a flag chance if BB can snag 45 plus goals this season.

Plus Spargo

Agree that's one of his plusses up forward his straight kicking!

Many AFL players develop at different rates and Locky has only 2 years Smithy sadly injured fir a great proportion of his 3. Maybe you believe we should not have even kept them in our list. I believe my positive opinions about them will bear fruit this season as they will develop and eradicate their missing elements! Most players are still works in progress and fulfilment of potential is not an exact science. Jay and Joel deserve this season and I will be surprised if given an equal opportunity they don't succeed.

DrD I found BRF's summary of 2019 and 2020 Both insightful and largely factual. Also His excellent listing of the potential of growth from our 2017,18, 19 and 20 recruits this season, and the effects of Ooze and Choco plus BBB when available. I also am bullish about improvement from our 22-26 yo olds and would add Hunt ANB Gus Tommo Petty Fritsch plus Salem as candidates to improve our team. Consequently your QUARTER GLASS FULL response absolutely amazes me.It completely overlooks natural improvement ( already documented in Training and Track watchers posts) plus two virtual new recruits in Petty and Brown and the already positive 2020 start at their new Club. Yes we have been Fooled more than 40 times in the last 56 when hoping for a Finals berth and only twice played off ( very disappointingly) For our 13th Flag. That overrides many pundits and comments are therefore general and historically based. I look at each year for the Signs and potential positively and believe our list and Club are nearing the time when all the jigsaw pieces are due to click ( In spite of Goody) and substance in our faith will be rewarded. Lets hope this happens and surprises the sceptics!

Relax 2021 will prove that our rebuild Is well underway much quicker than the naysayers are telling or forecasting. Be prepared to apologise in September and embrace the force and extent of the Melbourne Comeback.

WWSW you are falling for the trick many D/L ers do. They fail to give our players a chance to develop and improve. Both Locky and Smithy have got plenty of room fir improvement and have potential as senior AFL players. A season or even half should bring them along nicely as our defence has started to become quite reliable and now act as a team defence at long last. Godfrey was middling and I presume you are posting about Oscar, who was a trier but could not fill the key FB or CHB to the level required.

Well WWSW Whst I am saying is that too often we get beaten by the small forwards not having a small defender quick and smart enough to mind them. In the same game Daniels kicked 3 goals snd nobody bear him so he was the most likely player to kick a goal/s and win the game. I believe Lockhart is our Jetta replacement and Yes Smithy was much better at the end of 2020 as he seemed to alter his approach and Gain an appreciation of what an AFL footballer needs to do. His footy smarts seem to have improved also.credit to the coaches for this and Joel. Smith is depth and Reasonably versatile and I look forward to his season But am very bullish about Locky's potential long term future at the Dees as a regular member of the improving team this year and many years ahead.

And how many have openly stated that on our list? Rufus name all the names please.

Although Joel improved at the end of 2020 in the last 3/4 games and showed some aptitude to add to his athleticism and energy give me a natural instinctive footballer with skills and dare to break lines. Locky should have the Back pocket minding small opponents for a few years if he is given the opportunity by Goody. Joel could hold down a back flank on a bigger opponent if need be If he continues to develop his game awareness. Is versatile which could be a huge advantage with our depth in the future.

Getting more like the Finals team WD Locky for Hunt in BP Rosman for Baker On wing Hibbo for ANB and on HB flank moving Spargo to HF and Salem an Inter. Harmes stays in and Hunt Baker and ANB are Emergencies with

Ditto

Possibly the players were given their own programs to do by Burgo for the Jan start WFA so in part we are both correct but reckon he was in Tas home doing his private prep so no CluB contact available to Big Ben then. Let's hope comes back as the real McCoy with 50 goals this season.

Very big Thanks to all the track watchers and reports that we are getting. Priceless info on differing methods About players and the best is their training and development. Every now- and again I twitter to myself about something or a gem From a post . At this stage From the training reports I have about 2/3 of our list improving of our older 21plusses and all the 2019 and 2020 draftees developing nicely. Finally Hunt Salem Fritsch look as though they are going to become close to the players they were recruited 3 to 5 years ago. And fabulous to hear that all the D/L ers lining up Charlie as The Oscar bagging clone will have to find another Player. Sparrow Jordan and Lockhart plus the young Tyros Jacko Kossie Riv plus Ros Laurie and Bowey are creating a standard that is well overdue with theIf talent and potential. Of course having Maxy Maysie Trac AndClarry setting the Standards overall Is of great comfort as is Choco and Ooze Running the drills. Surely we can improve our footy in the wind because we don't play our games at Marvel and MCG all the time esp in aCovid year!! Thanks again Track watchers Your efforts are greatly appreciated.

Actually Jets played vs GWS (and Bombers I am Sure) but past his prime. We need a specialist small defender andLocky is the man most suited.Not always do your best 22 make the best Team as you have to have horses for courses.For some reason Goody decided Locky was not in or team at the end and IMO has put Locky's career back about half a season. Should start again in BP or on the oppos best small. I don't think Salo has that extra pace to mind Tippy fir eg. Hibberd and Riv are more mediums and Mind the Fritsch size forwards. Rivers could mind a small but is suited to mediums and Hibbo can go tall at a pinch. Riv May even get midfield or forward time in due course such is his talent and ability. About the Interchange Salem won't be on the bench very long. And he can play HB HF and wing (at a pinch ) Plus on the ball fir a quick stint. Tommo is versatile CHB or key defender across HF to defend vs a good oppo defender like Haynes etc. also in ruck and on the wing. Sparrow on the ball can play up forward and Jordon again on the ball down back. Lastly Gus on the ball and floating up forward provides options. So that bench is more in line with greater flexibility that Dogga Tommy Petty Rosman Tommo Salem Fritsch ( please leave him forward) and a Trac and a couple of others that will give our team a completely new look and versatility that will surprise even our fans and the opposition of course. All we have to do us get Goody to embrace these changes early i the season and quite frankly the earlier the better for our Finals and team development.

DS don't mind your Baker summary Actually he plays more like a Half forward than a wingman ( at least the game vs GWS which he kicked those great goals. But let's look at fitness and tank after the pre:season and practice games to see where he is at. Rosman has that already pace and endurance so he is a mile ahead of Baker and skills also I bet. Milkshake wouldn't run at HF so why ask him to run both ways like Langdon No Melky is on the edge IMO and only blackmail by Goody as his friend can save his spot. Please also agree about Tommy wing is only for about3 mins and also dies t he have a rest also? Salem or Hunt would be my choice to try but actually very happy if Fraser earns his song spot Ashe is doing his level best to do. Also let's not fall into the trap that all he can do is run His marking kicking and goal scoring are also being noted by the pundits and on doubt the Coaches. If I was a betting man Ros gets first go on the wingopposite Langers and we have two running beasts that will bring our team attacking and connection up forward ahead a long way. Laurie from the reports today is also making good his running and disposal skills so that augurs well for our flanks for the future.