Jump to content

Greendale

Members
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Greendale

  1. Greendale replied to Josh's post in a topic in Melbourne Demons
    Eddie, Kingy and Derm whinging about taunting in the game, and they only show the Vanders example. Of course they don't talk about Max being targeted off the ball, including being repeatedly punched in the chest in the first quarter. Or maybe they could talk about McHenry going after May after the ball is gone. Biased umps and biased commentary.
  2. Greendale replied to Josh's post in a topic in Melbourne Demons
    Umps have let Adelaide get away with this niggle all game. Just as they've let Max be tackled in the ruck and Taylor Walker has been allowed to shephard in the marking contest multiple times. Two free kicks for us that quarter is [censored] [censored]
  3. How I felt watching tonight's game
  4. Agree with the entire post, but this bit really sticks out for me. Did we have any tactics whatsoever in the first quarter? Didn't run from half back at all. Didn't use the corridor at all. The players looked completely content to just keep going down the line straight to the Port outnumber, even though they were putting goal after goal on the scoreboard. What had Goodwin and the other coaches actually worked on during the week?
  5. Hey we actually got some run of half back. What a crazy idea
  6. This is happening to us every week due to our tap dominance. Around the clearances the other clubs are just clinging on to our midfielders and then breaking into space when we turn it over. Need to change our system around the ball to find more seperation.
  7. Who gives a [censored] if it's a report Hamish. You've got the vision right in front of you to see that there was nothing in it. Move on you moron
  8. Port are consistently getting the ball out the front of the stoppage with forward handballs. St.Kilda completely stopped this last week by getting a winger off the back of the stoppage.
  9. Was it Fritsch who gave away a stupid 50 like that a couple of weeks ago? I know someone did
  10. Pure idiocy from Fritsch
  11. Grow some balls goal umpire
  12. What is wrong with that umpire seriously
  13. McCluggage killing us with his clean hands. Always hitting running players
  14. Goodwin said in his presser yesterday that the rest of the group would join next Friday.
  15. Surely we don't have the salary cap space for a player the calibre of Williams? In the last few years we've picked up Lever, May, Tomlinson and Langdon. Add that on top of the likes of Gawn, Oliver, TMac and Trac, and I'd imagine that our cap would be fairly full.
  16. Greendale replied to Josh's post in a topic in Melbourne Demons
    13 touches at 53% efficiency after 11 with 72% the week before. Four clangers in both games. His pressure is undoubtedly very good but for me his ball use has been lacking. I don't think he's been terrible but Jones and Tomlinson would both be gunning for his spot, and I think we need to always drive high standards.
  17. I think we'll know in 5 or 6 years time. I just think it's a big gamble that I'm not sure we needed to make. I'll be very happy to be proven wrong if Jackson reaches his undoubtedly high potential.
  18. Greendale replied to Josh's post in a topic in Melbourne Demons
    Lockhart, Jackson, Brayshaw -> Rivers, TMac, Jones Jackson shows plenty of promise, but I still think that TMac currently offers more. Lockhart and Brayshaw have had two poor games in a row, and considering the fixture squeeze that's going to be coming up, I think it's important to keep players fresh. Vandenberg on notice, Tomlinson a possibility to replace.
  19. Both will be very good, but Pickett is a better fit for our team. Weightman plays very similarly to Hannan, while Pickett offers something different with his extra crumbing and pressure.
  20. In that scenario we would maintain picks 10 and 28. The only difference would be Jackson and the picks I listed.
  21. At least Breust isn't out there today. He hates us.
  22. Clarko giving us a hell of a lot more credit than the commentators. Looks shocked
  23. Joke of a non-call there
  24. Scully weak again. Love it
  25. Gawn is murdering them in the ruck. If Oliver can tidy up a little we could really slaughter them in the centre clearances. Would make a big difference considering that we've locked them in their defensive 50 quite well.