Elegt

Unfortunately he had a chris dawes mare in round 1

Jesse Hogan is the most overrated player in the league.

I'm not talking about Treloar's first 5 years or saying Clayton won't be better than Treloar. I just believe if you play a game today with all of those players lining up Treloar would be the first picked. He is a gun

Good player pre brain surgery. I'd take him

nope, he's a dud

Treloar came 4th in the brownlow a few years ago, Clarry hasn't come close to winning it

Think you quoted the wrong post mate

Treloar is better than viney Oliver and Brayshaw

His kicking was terrible, probably why I reckon

Well they are related

Should be playing in the forward pocket IMO

Don't know why we recruited another Wagner after our first

He tried hard but really was on the list for too long

Been told today by the pies he is not wanted

You are so far off the mark its not even funny -lever struggled this year and didn't offer more than frost was offering. C grade at best -langdon is a b grader-cant kick -viney is a butcher, would struggle to get a game at Richmond -brayshaw can only play one position and can't kick, again would be a fringe player at a top side -hibberd struggled to get a consistent spot in our team this year, c grader -tomlinson struggled to get a game too-c grader -harmes couldn't even get a game -luke jackson and tmac were preferred over press, he has no tank and is a liability once the ball hits ground Sorry but you really need to re analyse the list, we would be winning flags if the list was as good as you're saying

But he lacked pace...

His game against Essendon was one of the worst games I've ever seen a Melbourne player play

Wouldn't mind jack Higgins

Terrible season to be honest

Didn't go anywhere near addressing our deficiencies though. Pickett would've been ideal. Mistakes happen I understand but I'm just so fed up with the recruiting over the past decade. Of course mainly prendagasts fault rather than Taylor but I really think we need to recruit faster players

Tomlinson is a plodder, moves like Tom mcdonald. Also mid season draft is a great opportunity to take a risk to bolster up your deficiencies, instead Taylor decided to continue with the slow inside mid trend

We have a plethora of slow inside mid... Taylor has not drafted one player with a solid amount of pace bar pickett. Id also argue langdon isn't quick but has great endurance

He was bracing. Things look worse in slow motion but there was no intent to hurt the bloke

Dunkley is no different to the Wagner's, looked a mile off it

Trengove was never really that good