Elegt

I will never renew my membership if Nathan Jones is selected next week. Bloke has been a fantastic player but the game has passed him by and its time for him to retire

Why is it stupid? Seems like you have similar concerns to myself

He is mobile and tends to bring the ball to ground. I'd much rather him at FF than Weid or Tmac

Yep and we could've drafted Georgiades. We picked 2 players ahead of him

I think the mistake was hoping Jackson would be a good forward option, given he never played there as a Junior, better to get a more natural forward if that is the ultimate aim. Sure he may be a great ruckman one day but he's never going to be a buddy franklin

nope, hence why I gave blokes like angus brayshaw and jayden hunt a success

why one more game back? plonk him at FF

Because this crap has been going on for years. Lets run through his entire drafting/trading history 2013 Trades: Viv Michie for 54-error Tyson 9 + 53 for 2 + 20 + 72 -error Vince for 23-success Draft Salem 9- success Kennedy Harris 40-error Jayden Hunt 57-success Harmes 2-success Rookie King 19-error Georgieou 35-error 2014 Trades Garlett + 83 for 61 + 79- success Lumumba for Mitch Clark-error Frost + 40 + 53 for 23 - error Draft Petracca 2 - success Brayshaw 3- success Neal Bullen 40- error Mcdonald 53-error Rookie Vandenburg 2-success White 20-error 2015 Trades Melksham for 25-success Howe and Toumpas for Kennedy 29 + 50-error Fitzpatrick for 94-success Bugg and 7 for 10 + 43 +64- success Draft Oliver 4-success Weideman 9- error King 42-error Hulett 46-error Rookie Wagner 6-error Smith 41- neutral 2016 Trades 29 + 68 for Hibberd and 59 -success Dunn and 51 for 47-error Draft Hannan 46-neutral Johnstone 64-error Rookie Filipovic 8-error Smith 25-error Kielty 41-error 2017 Trades 10 + 2018 (1rd) + 2018 (4rd) for Lever + 35 + 2018 (3rd rd)- error Watts for 31 -success 66 for Balic-error Draft Spargo 29- error Fritsch 31-success Petty 37-error Baker 48-error 2018 Trades Kent for 65-error Tyson for Preuss + 62-neutral Hogan + 65 for 6 + 23-success May + Kolodjasnij for 6 -neutral however Ben King looks to be a star and Kolodjasnij will be delisted Draft Sparrow 27-neutral but did we really need another inside mid Jordon 33-neutral but this kid should be pushing for games by now Nietschke 53-error Hore 56-success Bedford 75-neutral Rookie Chandler 15-error Mid-Season Dunkley 3-error 2019 Frost + 42 + 61 + 2020 4th rnd for 50 + 2020 2nd rd-neutral 22 + 79 + 2020 2nd rd for Langdon 26 + 2020 4th rd-neutral 26 + 50 2020 1st rnd for 8 [pickett]-neutral but looks like error at this stage Draft Jackson 3-neutral but Hayden Young is what we needed Pickett 12- neutral but kid has a long way to go Rivers 32-neutral but the kid looks to have the goods Overall more misses than hits

Harmes has been played in the backline for nearly 2 years now and has been rotating through the wing. He is rubbish in those two positions. Time to move him forward

Seems to me like Steven May is the best leader we have

Both are lucky to be included given how bad they were on Thursday

Admittedly I havent watched much of North but I always thought Polec was average

Reminds me of Jimmy Toumpas

Baker and jordon definetly, but dunkley is slower than gus. Definetly not suited for the wing

Gee we are still having similar problems to the ones we had years ago. Our wingers at stages last night were jones and gus. Our new winger tomlinson can't even get a game. Still really lack runners with a inside mid dominated midfield

Nah but seriously, this kid has a good future ahead of him. Isn't afraid to ask the hard questions and interviewing technique is spot on.

Ben is fantastic and im especially liking his pre game videos. Perhaps the best recruit for the dees at this point in time. Chuck him at FF! Can't do any worse than tmac

I could rephrase to "why the hell do we have no good young players"

Play the ball not the man

Surely the chief recruiter is involved in trading

Seems like you're the only poster on here who's not afraid to speak up and demand change. Too many optimists on here

clearly not picking the right players for us. Wasting draft picks. Why these guys are on our list bewilders me -wagner brothers -kolodjasnij -baker -spargo -chandler -preuss -bradke Questionable selections -pickett for a first rounder, quite possibly the number 1 pick -passing on hayden young (great footskills off the hbf. Exactly what we need) -recruiting lever and may with 3 first round picks -getting two wingers who can't kick -jordon with a second rounder Taylor needs to go

This just infuriates me and highlights the losing mentality of this club 3. Don't bloody blame injuries for 2019s terrible performance. We have a full strength side in with no injuries and are still getting destroyed 4 . Another ridiculous injury excuse 5. Tomlinson is rubbish. Neither of these blokes can kick. Why add people to our squad that can't kick when we already have the worst disposal in the league 6. How does a ruckman get that role and beat 3 others??!!! Astounding!! 7. Yep and we still suck. Injuries are no excuse 8. Well this didnt work. Probably should’ve reviewed the prelim

sack Taylor for recruiting this spud with such a high pick

Itd be nice if this bloke learnt how to man up. He must think social distancing applies on the footy field