The Swimming Dee

I think Viney should have another week off. He has rushed it too many times before and a 3/4 fit Jack has performed badly in the past. Just my opinion. No change or Preuss for Kielty if they decide to bring in the big boy

Thanks for the tip champ but not sure I made any claims I cannot back up

Gee you are very defensive of poor Tom...is that you Tom? Last night he said that May had been at the pub until 6.00pm and had "ample beers". It is crap journalism....end of story.

Agree May should be more careful. But Morris’ story is bloke went to pub and had a few beers...give me a break. Where did Tom get the story from his instadh account. FFS what has the world become

Tom Morris is just jealous he has no mates to go for a beer with. If he is a journalist with any integrity, I have played 300 elite games at AFL level. What an overreaction

Tom Morris = absolute [censored]

No excuse for this rubbish at the footy. One of the great things about our game is that going to a game is a family safe environment. Ban the bloke for life, we don’t want peanuts like that supporting our club

I thought Billy was ok Dazzle. IMO he needs to work on pulling the trigger on the kick and taking the game on a bit. He seems too risk averse at times...might just be a confidence thing though

Weideman will be a player WTM, but Naughton is something seriously special!

Sorry mate I rate you as a poster but have to disagree. Watch the replay and you will see him give up the advantage position on multiple occasions and then throw his weak arm up and watch while a hawks player marks the ball...no intensity and no aggression. He has a better football brain than Frost but lacks the aggression and proactiveness required. His last quarter almost cost is the game too...there is no denying that

All good mate, I’m not looking for an argument. I just think that Oscar is so reactionary. He had the advantage in a marking contest against Gunston I think it was and waited for him to go to the ball, then the ball was kicked to him and he didn’t go at it and got beaten again. Frost at least went at the ball and made an impact/ something happen. I just don’t get the lack of intensity. There is no doubt he uses the ball well by foot but he ain’t getting us over the line in a one one one in a GF...Frost might though

I’ll agree to disagree but imo as soon as we have Lever or May in the team OMac will be playing VFL. Hore and Frost are miles ahead of him. BTW Frost maybe won us the game late by his positive proactive acts

Just re watched some of the games. Harmes BOG by a mile. A serious game by him. Well done lad!

Agree whole heartedly

His last quarter was disgusting. He nearly lost us the game when it was all on the line. He did not attack the ball and that is inexcusable. I was a fan but after what i saw today Frost is miles ahead of him

Never been on this thread before but just want to say that Aaron Naughton is a GUN!

6 Harmes 5 Gawn 4 Salem 3 Oliver 2 Lockhart 1 Hibberd Harmes and Gawn were huge today. Honourable mentions to Frost and Hore

I thought Hunt was very good today and is doing a good job of reinventing himself

He is a reactionary footballer with no intensity. I don’t want to dwell on the negatives but his last quarter nearly cost is the game

Gawn was also huge today. He destroyed McEvoy

He is the small forward we need at the moment. Tackles hard, is confident enough to go up the ground and has footy smarts. I like his hard edge

Lockhart was very good. He laid some good tackles also

What a game from Harmes!

Hats off to Frost. Huge last couple of minutes. See ya Oscar

Oscar you are awful