Billy

I agree, it’s a disgrace some very very very average players are getting a game in front of Laurie

Josh Daicos can play a bit & is a better bloke than his brother

What in Gods name has Tholstrup done to warrant selection

Yep if we don’t move with Goodwin, he will keep playing his washed up favourites in 2026 to the detriment of the long term development of younger players

Has just put all contract negotiations on hold, a West Australian who wants to play as an attacking half back instead of a lockdown back pocket Another unhappy Demon Maybe we need a new coach in 2026???

I don’t know why you support this club anymore and this coming from a person who thinks Gawn has no leadership qualities. Never read a positive post from you

Yep he’s not up to VFL standard let alone AFL standard atm Let’s hope a full preseason may help in 2026

Out Oliver, Fritsch, Jefferson Tholstrop & Sharp In Laurie Windsor Kenterfield, Culley & Tmac

Seriously You obviously don’t pay any attention to the Casey games Laurie has been probably the best Melbourne listed player for the year And you think Goodwin will lose respect by playing him, that respect was lost 2 years ago

No idea, so over Goodwin

I agree but hoping that Lever can get his ankle right, people forget that he had little or no pre season & problems with it during the season, he’s a pro & a good leader, can’t believe how people are writing him off so quickly As for Petracca, he’s talked the talk, the club really needs to work out his loyalty and love for the club. He’s a high profile star, it was this time last year he’d had a life threatening injury, time for him to walk the walk. If not trade him

I’d just be happy to have a CEO that’s actually at the club NOW, along with a President We must be the only club that can self destruct so quickly after a premiership I really thought after 2021 we had finally become a respectable organisation What a joke we are

I’d keep them both, with a new coach & see how it goes in 2026, if it’s a complete failure move them on in 2027

We are a year further down the track than Carlton, our game style is the same as Carlton, we’ve had an internal & external review, no president a new CEO that’s probably having second thoughts (don’t blame him) & yet it looks like Goodwin will see out his contract He really needs to be gone at seasons end, the message & game plan ain’t getting through

Laurie has never been given the chance to prove himself, a couple of sub appearances as a pressure forward doesn’t count That’s another fail by the coach

Pickett genuinely interested in your thoughts regarding what we do with Clarry I like you have been his No1 &No2 fan of him & rate him when at his prime as one of our best ever Don’t know where it goes from here?

P

Petracca orLever

Mungrel would’ve been a better word

What????

Melksham Pickett Petracca Bowey Rivers Viney

Is Jefferson the sub?

Where is Joe Gutnick when you need him Oh that’s right we don’t have a president or CEO

Poor Voss & Goodwin gets away Scott free

Agreed but what about Petty?