Waltham33

Ive cheered him and James on this year. They made career choices as we all would. Still a loss but looking forward

I don't think the challenge is the injuries, more wear and tear that is not obviously evident and the forward line. Don't mind the thought of managing some players this year and going hard in 2025 if we don't turn things around in the next 2 weeks

Couldnt be asking for more form him. Very dependable and deserves some praise. Team has never been the same since he did his foot in 2022

6- ANB 5- Gawn 4- Rivers 3 - Kozzie 2 - TMAc 1 - Salem

Cant keep reflecting on past decisions, no doubt some decisions look incorrect in hindsight. The key now is recruiting real FA talent and trading in the right players, not top up. I know every club is trying to do that however if we dont win well in October with trades and signings, 2025 will be another disappointing year

6 - Gawn 5- Trac 4- Tommo 3- Tmac 2- Viney 1 - Salem

Turning the ball over at a frightening rate. Also their midfield is very one paced so they have been exposed for leg speed. If they fix their turnovers they will win games sure enough

Pressure their midfield they cough it up. Let Matt Crouch kick long all day

As they should - at our best no one touches us. If the club is taking that mindset I applaud it!

Injuri3s are part of the game, never let them sour a win. Great test for the remaining defenders. Hawthorn were well on top for parts of qtr 2 and 3, just couldn’t score. Our ball movement is great

Petty back settled the back 6 yesterday. Tommo in and ultimately it’s about how easy the opposition get it in their 50. Lock them down mids

You would be a fool to underestimate them. Some great talent coming through and well coached.

If you have to provide excessive concessions for new clubs at this stage it says little for why you need the club.

The answer to all your questions is money

Really enjoyed watching him today - great talent

6. May 5. Gawn 4. Clarry 3. Trac 2. Chandler 1. TMac

May, now Roffey there seems to be an obsession with Collingwood 😁

Need BBB or TMac in to at the least take the top defender ala Frampton in the GF last year.

It’s been a long term tactic to let the less efficient users get a lot of it. So,metimes it’s hurts the team

Give me more of that disposal efficiency

Totally agree - maybe though Fullarton was the only one that was interested

Grundy - woops 6- Viney 5- May 4- Mcvee 3- Salem 2- tommo 1- Bowey

Will get worse until we address the physicality on Gawn. Clubs know there is no ready made backup.

Very funny thread this one. Really hoping Tom goes next level and he has that opportunity.

Changing leaders would have likely brought even more external scrutiny imho. Stability is the message here and agree with view one captain is on field focused and the other captain is off field focused.