At the break of Gawn

My point is that he's not some superstar talent we're letting go through the door with you calling it a "terrible result for the footy club". I actually think AMW would've overtaken him next year anyway.

Got no coaches votes this year. Average player rating of just 6.3 (career highest average rating of 9.2 in 2024) You are really overrating him here. And before you say he's a 3rd year player, Will Ashcroft is also in his 3rd year.

Wow, so much outrage for a guy who even if he played all 23 games wouldn't have finished top 10 or top 15 in our BnF this year. Let him go to Freo. I would be surprised if he starts in their 22 by round 1. He's not a dashing half back, his decision making is too slow as a midfielder, and as a small defender I've seen him be toweled up by Rankine and Higgins far too many times See ya Judd.

Anyone see Scott's post match presser? Started his own monologue before any questions, again alluded to "extenuating circumstances", "challenges within the playing group" blah blah blah which none of it he would not elaborate on. Almost the exact same way he spoke about the 2021 prelim loss. Since 2013, Geelong are 1 flag from 9 prelims. Since 2012: Flags won: Geelong 1, Melbourne 1. Scott may be a terrific home and away coach but he's got nothing on Clarkson or Hardwick when it comes to finals.

It was refreshing to hear Goody admit this, however I think part of our problem in some ways was how dominant our finals series and the age of our list. We made basically 0 list changes at the end of 2021 and there was basically no new players to come in with new hunger to win a flag. We rested on our laurels in a whole club sense. Geelong made significant list changes after their 2022 premiership (albeit some forced due to age) to a point where there 2025 team is almost unrecognisable to their 2022 team. Even Mitchell said in his presser after the prelim that they have to keep innovating because if they don't, they'll finish bottom 10 next year. Melb of 2021 did a Blockbuster. Geelong of 2022 did a Netflix.

I hope Steven King has already asked Selwyn to get a high performance program going like this.

I suspect it's because Melbourne's list management is actually open to the right trade. It's all in a holding pattern anyway until King comes on board.

Unbelievable effort by Brisbane to make 3 consecutive grand finals. What a time to be alive to be a Brisbane supporter. Especially when they won it last year. As a supporter you could probably just enjoy the week much more this time and not feel as anxious. Pies will slide out of the 8 next year. They went all in this year with their list and fell short. If Hill, Miocek and Elliot all go, I'd almost tip them to be bottom 6.

Genuinely annoying that the Melb v Dogs GF was in Perth. Two teams that aren't there that often and two Melb clubs (I'd count Geelong as Victorian but not a Melbourne club). The last time a GF was like that was 2010 (Pies v Saints). Another Geelong grand final is just becoming boring.

Would be amazing. Hope it's true.

Well done on calling it early. Will be good for the club.

Wouldn't be touching him.

💯 Agree. Wouldn't touch him. Chaplin is a far better assistant to lead the defence. King worked with Jennings at the Dogs who has been great at GWS.

I wonder if the work experience kid running our social media made an error sending out the tweet which disabled comments on the post or perhaps they were worried a few Melb supporters would have gone to town with "good riddance" on the comments...

I've been super impressed with all of King's media appearances so far. I have to admit, when it was announced, I was like "what about Bucks?". But after listening to King speak, his conviction with what he believes this team can deliver, and his confidence leaves me feeling very optimistic for 2026. In some ways, I can understand why Buckley wasn't chosen. He's been out of the industry for so long that you've got these assistant coaches in clubland who are up to date on the latest strategies, technology, stats that only clubs have access to, which would leave someone in the media for 5 years way behind in trying to win that job. Honestly, if Tassie don't run a proper process and just hire Bucks, they're derelict in their duties, and probably just reaffirms that it'll just be an ambassador type role for a few years like Sheedy was for GWS. Also with King, I wouldn't be surprised after hearing him speak, someone like Petracca would start to reconsider about being traded. Unless it's someone like Hawthorn, he could end up making it worse for himself.

The social media intern at it again https://x.com/SeanBalor/status/1966558289769996630?t=QPHn9FOcN7r8bYWAimOX_A&s=19

Maybe I'm listening to too much of Cornes because he went on a 20 minute rant yesterday about Merrett being a poor clubman and captain.

Skipworth was never going to get it. He pulled out just to save face. This is a guy who lost to McQualter for the Eagles job. Bullet dodged imo. King on the other hand, probably would have won the Eagles job had it not been for his health scare on the day of his interview. I liked the idea of Bucks because I thought his profile would help the club, but, I and many others on here, had lingering doubts about his ability to actually coach. Just ask any Collingwood supporter and they get confused as to why everyone was keen on Bucks. The club has run a proper process and King was the best candidate. Let's get behind him. I'm looking forward to the first King's speech to the playing group which hopefully they share on social media.

The pre-finals bye has really taken away the advantage. I really feel that in 2021, the no bye really helped us continue our momentum into that QF. Thankfully it seems like they're scrapping it for a pre-grand final bye like they did in 2021 and matches that of the NFL.

Apparently the record is 8. He's not far off breaking it...

Port 2023 probably comes close but that's about it. Fogarty played some of the worst finals I've seen for a forward (including Curnow).

ANB 0-6 in his last 6 finals. Unbelievably unlucky.

So he was our second choice? "Nathan Buckley's presence was a curiosity all along as Bucks was interviewing Melbourne as much as they were interviewing him," he said. "Right at the end, he couldn't answer the question if they offered him the job would he take it and I know Tasmania plays a role in that somewhere."