WERRIDEE

Great to see Hunt out been pathetic. How Ben Brown gets a game I do not know? Rewarding mediocrity Hopefully disco replaces Tommo but I wouldn’t hold my breath.

Hunt shouldn't play give the job to Rivers or Salem.

How can they not have Angus Brayshaw in it?

I thought it was him but he played last week.

I think I've made it clear about what I think of Tommo, but I'd seriously consider replacing Sparrow with Rivers use Rivers more as a midfielder.

I'm just wondering if anyone watched Tomlinson's game last week? How on earth should he be retained? Why should Spargo be dropped? Who is sideshow bob? Weideman never played. IN: Bedford, Hibberd, Turner OUT: Hunt, Tomlinson, B.Brown

Hypocrite! I blame the defence and you blame the midfield. And my comment is awful. No one should except mediocrity. They are mediocre players that should be replaced hopefully they will be replaced by Hibberd and Turner respectively. I do think they cost us the game and I don't see anything wrong with that.

It's not just the player it's who we replace him with. Our backline has been in disarray without him. Tomlinson along with Hunt and Lever cost us the game against Sydney. I'm confident Hunt won't play but Tomlinson I'm not sure .Give the kid Turner a go can't be any worse than Tomlinson.

Because of May we have lost this game. If we play Tomlinson it’s game over hopefully we can debut Turner

I think Bedford deserves an extended run that's why I would play one less tall and bring in Bedford.

I don't know about bringing in Weid he's had too many chances. Should we go smaller. HF: Neal-Bullen, Jackson, Pickett F: Spargo, M.Brown, Fritsch Bedford on the pine.

43# Andy Moniz-Wakefield - Progressing nicely in the VFL might need to get a bit more of the football. 42# Judd McVee - Struggling to get a lot of the ball. Needs time. 41# Fraser Rosman - Improving slowly since he's gone down back. 40# Blake Howes - Looked promising early a foot injury has hampered his progress. 39# Deakyn Smith - Progressing steadily down back. 38# Daniel Turner - Injured early has come back and looked impressive in the VFL. 37# Taj Woewodin - Has shown good signs on the wing. 36# Oskar Baker - Good form in the VFL but doesn't look like he has the abiltiy to turn that into good AFL form. 35# Majak Daw - Been solid in the ruck for Casey. You know what you get with Majak. 34# Jacob van Rooyen - Has shown promising signs in the VFL with a 6 goal haul against North. 33# Bailey Laurie - Shown promising signs in the VFL and been close to selection 32# Kade Chandler - Hasn't had a real run at it this year the suspension cost him dearly. 31# Jake Melksham - Cooked at AFL level but trying had at VFL level. 30# Michael Hibberd - Been injured for most of the year. Starting to find some form at VFL level. 29# Adam Tomlinson - Good form in the VFL but it's not transforming to good AFL form. 28# Mitch Brown - Excellent form at VFL level. Worth persisting with at AFL level 27# Sam Weideman - Good VFL form not turning into good AFL form like Tomlinson. 26# Joel.Smith - Was really starting to find his feet at AFL level until he done his ankle. Injury prone. 25# Luke Dunstan - Been a disappointing recruit. Accumulator but doesn't hurt the opposition. 24# Jayden Hunt - Been really poor the last month. Needs to find some form. Doing the small forward lockdown role. 23# Trent Rivers - Disappointing year not up to the lofty heights from his premiership year. 22# Ben Brown - Disappointing year. Last month has been putrid, needs to find some form. 21# Toby Bedford - The super sub. Showed promisng form has pace to burn and could be dangerous in tandem with Spargo and Pickett. 20# Tom Sparrow - Struggled of late needs to find consistantcy. 19# James Harmes - Been ok but needs to find a bit more of the ball. 18# Christian Salem - Been injured most of the year. Showed good signs against Sydney 17# Luke Jackson - Not putting his stamp on the game liek he should be time to step up. 16# Jake Bowey - Early in the year he was a rising star favorite struggled a little bit of late. 15# Harison Petty - Missed the whole pre season starting to play some good footy. 14# Alex Neal-Bullen - Not hitting the scoreboard but still playing his role. 13# Charlie Spargo - Similar to Neal-Bullen. 12# Tom McDonald - Strugled early but really started to hit his straps before he got injured. 11# Kysiah Pickett - Electrifying at his best the best defensive player in the comp. 10# Jake Lever - Not as good as last year. 9# James Jordon - Revelation on the wing this year. 8# Jack Viney - The heart and soul of the footy club still playing some great footy. 7# Ed Langdon - Best wingman in the comp. 6# Bailey Fritsch - Our only consistant forward. 5 Christian Petracca - Controversial most people would have him in the best 2 or 3 but I don't think he has had as good a year as he did last year. 4 Angus Brayshaw - Has been a revelation down back in All Australian form. 3 Steven May - Showed his importance with his absence. The rock of the back line. 2 Clayton Oliver - Never puts in a bad game. 1 Max Gawn - The best player in the league.

I can't believe how many people want Tomlinson in the side he is a spud. Turner is a better option.

IN: Weideman, May, Hibberd Out: Hunt, Tomlinson, B.Brown Hunt and Tomlinson aren't AFL standard players having them out will make us a 5 goal better team. Brown is playing like as VFL player sub standard performances 3 weeks. Massive chance for Weid he's had a million chances hopefully he can grab this one.

Melbourne B: Lever, May, Hibberd HB: Brayshaw, Petty, Salem C: Langdon, Petracca, Jordon HF: Neal-Bullen, McDonald, Pickett F: Fritsch, M.Brown, Spargo FOLL: Gawn, Oliver, Viney IC: Bowey, Harmes, Sparrow, Jackson SUB: Rivers If McDonald doesn't come up play Weideman he should be carryover emergency anyway. Casey B: D.Smith, Tomlinson, Buntine HB: McVee, Turner, Hunt C: Baker, Dunstan, Woewodin HF: Melksham, van Rooyen, Chandler F: Bedford, B.Brown, Moniz-Wakefield FOLL: Daw, White, Munro IC: Laurie, Grey, Ellison, Josh.Smith, Koo

6 Gawn his best game ever 5 Viney 4 Jordon 3 Brayshaw 2 Fritsch 1 Petty

Firstly I want to talk about the elephant in the room the umpires they were putrid. If that's the best they can come up with the umpires are in a crisis. Secondly Sydney didn't have a bad player on the ground while we had 4. Lever was dreadful worst game he's played at the club but at least he has some credits in the bank. Hunt has lost me like a dear in the headlights he was tonight. Sick of his mistakes shouldn't play a game for Melbourne again. Heard Hibberd played well in the 2's a ready made replacement. Tomlinson is a VFL player nothing more. Time to look at Turner as a key back replacement instead of Tomlinson. Ben.Brown's last month has been putrid. Must be dropped even if that's to give Weid his 100th chance. Liked Mitch.Brown's game should be persisted with. Hopefully McDonald's injury isn't that bad. On the positive side Max Gawn showed a master class tonight. Is there nothing he can't do?

He's the best player I've seen, definitely the best ruckman of all time. He's played plenty of good games but I think none better than tonight. He done everything to get us over the line tonight. Long live the great Max Gawn.

Reading all this I would have thought we were 5. Goals down we are only 2 points down calm the farm

VFL | Casey names magnificent seven (melbournefc.com.au) Don't know if there is another thread on this? if it is merge it. Strong side 16 Melbourne listed players playing. Bedford obviously the medi sub.

Interested in demonlanders thoughts on a player coming back from a long lay off.

I thought Weitering would be in the side. Have they got an All Stars team to compare?

He played on Hogan and killed him. He can play down back just like McDonald. Why can't you get it through your thick skull?

It like saying McDonald can't play back because he's a forward. Brown has proven he can play back and when has Weideman actually been in form he's always out of form.

If they had him as a sub last week he would have played defence. He gives us flexibility unlike a Dunstan who can only play midfield. He has played defence at VFL level. A better option than Weid. He can play small similar to Fritsch.