Jump to content

Machsy

Members
  • Posts

    4,401
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    4

Posts posted by Machsy

  1. They were negotiating for an extension.

    He had 1 year left on his contract, and St Kilda at the time were copping criticism for letting it get to that point when he was clearly one of the best coaches in the game

    That's how I remember it. Haven't checked old articles to confirm.

  2. I doubt he will leave the Cats and doubt they will delist/trade him.

    Trust me.

    Won't reveal my sources, but he will not be offered a new contract at Geelong.

    Hope we are "balls deep" in discussions with him, but at this stage I doubt it, since he's bent on staying at Geelong til they give him the official tap on the shoulder.

    The only way he stays is if Pods goes, and while that's a real chance, even then he's not likely to get a new contract.

    Chapman knows this.

  3. $400k is about 4% of the cap next year.

    So it is becoming less extravagant to pay someone that.

    Yes, but with 40 odd players on your list, they average 2.5% of the cap each.

    Obviously the players aren't equal, but there's a large difference between 2.5% and 4% for a kid going into his 3rd year.

    I'd pay it, but I think the 4% should be put in context.

  4. Source, DD? Is this now a done thing as of last night and merely yet to be announced?

    I read it somewhere earlier tonight.

    Maybe Caro's article?

    Sydney will concede we can have him since he commutes from Melbourne for work.

    • Like 1
  5. I don't think there are any "dud" candidates.

    There will just be one that is seen as being better than the others.

    The best part is that we'll have at least 2 years to make sure he's not another "Neeld" before he takes the reins.

    • Like 1
  6. yes we must trust PJ... but I spoke to Josh Mahoney mid-season and he said all travelling ok and with a bit more luck we will be competitive. I almost decked him ... LUCK!!!!

    What the hell did you expect him to say?

    Honestly, some people are just strange...

    I called this ages ago

    Knew he would stay on and get the gig, he is a very smart operator.

    Yeah, I think he comes across as an intelligent and capable operator.

    I was all for Geoff Walsh due to his excellent CV, but if we can't have him, I'm not unhappy with Mahoney.

    Especially if PJ has signed off on it.

    Congratulations Josh, it would seem you've earned it.

  7. Eddie gave it to us a "home game " every year.

    We do not have to share the gate every other year!

    Eddie is not the enemy in this instance.

    I'm sure Eddie likes to spout that its at his behest, but the AFL would make that decision.

    "Eddie, we give you only give you 1 Sunday game a year - the dees need QB and that's how it's gonna stay."

    • Like 1
×
×
  • Create New...