Match Report - Preliminary Final

[Demonland 72,185]

NO CONTEST by George On The Outer

This was the first finals series in which the Melbourne Football Club has participated for a dozen years and its first Preliminary Final for 18. The club got here in 2018 because it built its reputation on contest, but in the end the game against West Coast was no contest as the Eagles ran out winners by over ten goals.

The match itself was really over by quarter time, as the young Demons were simply swamped by a side that was bigger, stronger and ultimately had more intent on achieving its goal. 

The game, while disappointing from an outcome perspective, should motivate the Demons in the same way that the Round 22 match against Collingwood did last year.  It was what finals football was all about and while they had performed admirably in winning their past 2 matches to progress to the Preliminary, this was when things got serious.  

Melbourne was exposed in the same way that Richmond was exposed on Friday night because, to get into the Big Dance, you cannot afford to come into any game half-hearted, injured or with stop gap players.

Right from the start the Demons were in trouble, with errant handballs and players slipping constantly at critical moments. While West Coast scored four goals to zip in the first quarter, three of those came directly from Melbourne turnovers. Coupled with some undisciplined acts from Jordan Lewis, the momentum that a young team relied upon to forge forward was completely and utterly deflated.  

It didn’t get any better in the second quarter and by half time the Eagles held a ten goal lead, which was to be the final margin. The coach would have been fuming as he watched Melbourne revert to the old style of play of standing back and expecting others to do the work. I heard it mentioned that the Demons had only three tackles to ¼ time and a paltry 30 odd for the whole game - a poor result from a side that prides itself on contest. 
 
Statistics lovers would think Angus Brayshaw played a good game.  But stumbles, fumbles and miskicks don’t get recorded.  The stat which did get recorded was the eight clangers. The fact that he wasn’t on the ground for a majority of the third term indicates that something was wrong with him, and his grunt and surety was missed, despite the numbers.  

All around the ground, we were seeing structures which were not what had been seen in past weeks or months.  Tom McDonald was playing back, Aaron vndenBerg almost full time in the middle, Joel Smith supposedly selected as a backman spent most of the game forward.  When players are being thrown around like this, it can only mean that an attempt is being made to fill gaps.  

The result is the was little in the way of forward structure, but then the ball didn’t get down there until the second half of the game, and even then there was no genuine marking target.  How we would have relished Jesse Hogan in front of goal - perhaps next year?

The mids were simply destroyed, not from the clearances, but by the outside run which enabled them to deliver cleanly to their forwards in Darling, Kennedy, Cripps and LeCras.  As mentioned last week, when we have Jones and Tyson on the wing, there is no run for us, but importantly, they cannot keep up with the opposition.  Then with Alex Neal-Bullen able to just hit 50% disposal efficiency, it showed that even when we had the ball, we simply butchered it.

The forwards had a shocker of a day as well.  Without T McDonald there to provide a target for good parts of the game, the likes of Melksham, Hannan and Spargo rarely had a viable touch, with all of them barely into double figure disposals. Sam Weideman reverted to being unable to hold a mark this week, and Christian Petracca kept trying to give the ball off to others when inside 30m himself. His set shots were nothing to behold again.  Plenty of work needs to be done for him in this area over summer. 

The backs were overwhelmed by the amount of ball coming in, but the lack of composure was telling, especially compared with their work-rate last week.  Sadly, Oscar McDonald and Michael Hibberd failed to effect a single tackle, Sam Frost, Lewis and Christian Salem one each. Neville Jetta at least had three. 

The mids weren’t much better and their numbers were mostly twos and threes. Overall there were seven players who didn’t lay a single tackle in the game. Simply not good enough in any game, let alone a Preliminary Final.

Can the Demons learn from this game?  The coach has already indicated that contest is king and that is particularly the case in Finals, especially when you get to the pointy end. The fans can be proud and happy with the performance during the season, and have seen the results following years of promises and nothing to show but there has to be more.

And there is much more improvement to come, simply because the majority of this group is still young. They came up against a side on its home turf which played in a Grand Final just three years ago, finished the home and away  season in second spot and were handed (and took) the initiative in the first ten minutes of the game. They deserve to be Grand Finalists again this year, but we must learn to perform to the standard required to get to the final stage, that they displayed in this game ... an in particular, to always provide a contest.

I just can’t wait for the cricket and tennis to be over ...
 
Melbourne 0.3.3 0.6.6 5.9.39 7.13.55

West Coast Eagles 4.8.32 10.9.69 15.10.100 18.13.121

Goals 

Melbourne Melksham 2 Hannan Harmes Oliver J Smith Weideman

West Coast Eagles Kennedy 4 Cripps Darling LeCras 3, Hutchings Redden Rioli Ryan Venables

Best 

Melbourne Harmes Oliver vandenBerg Petracca J Smith Viney 

West Coast Eagles Kennedy Redden Cripps Hurn McGovern Sheed LeCras

Injuries 

Melbourne Nil 

West Coast Eagles Nil

Reports

Melbourne Nil 

West Coast Eagles Nil

Umpires Nicholls, Meredith, Chamberlain 

Official crowd 59,608 at Optus Stadium

[Gorgoroth 12,950]

Vanders improvements when thrown in the guts is a positive I’m taking out of the game, he could drop a few kgs over summer and be a real weapon. His don’t argues are pretty bloody good. 

Full pre season and fitness he could be a big inclusion, get Fritsch and Stretch on the wings offer the outside run we need.

[Bitter but optimistic 22,239]

That's a pretty fair summary George.

I saw the comment/ question raised on a couple of threads ( and I asked it myself during the game) - " why were our players losing their feet so often"?

Has anyone got an answer?

[frankie_d 1,471]

1 hour ago, Bitter but optimistic said:

That's a pretty fair summary George.

I saw the comment/ question raised on a couple of threads ( and I asked it myself during the game) - " why were our players losing their feet so often"?

Has anyone got an answer?

A number of the falls led to turnovers and goals - must be an answer - suspect footwear? I hope someone asks Goodwin - might be a detail that we missed?

And I hope Brayshaw (who tried his guts out, but was uncharacteristically sloppy) was not concussed last week .