Do player rankings have a point Stu?

Does personal hygiene ?

Does anything?

Come in Stu- you can get more outraged over something of no real consequence than this.

I just think some of the rankings are confusing.

On what basis is Hogan C grade? No matter how good he's looked in the VFL or a pre-season game, he's yet to debut.

Conversely, if he's C grade, how on earth is JKH, whose shown plenty, D grade?

Why is Michie E grade?? He's still pretty wet behind the ears as well.

The wait and see players shouldn't be graded at all, because we don't know yet.

I'd agree that Jones is our only A grader. Aspect of Frawley's game are A grade, but he is not a rounded A grader.

May not agree with much of the OP's list, but I do like reading these things. Cheers for the effort, guy.