We need a full-forward to kick 8

[Rogue 585]

Just when I think it's over...

You're like a monster from a bad horror movie

You've proved that anyone can kick a bag of 8, but I quickly changed that to bags, which happened before you started naming names. I did this because I don't think the OP wanted a flash in the pan, I'm pretty sure they wanted someone who could do it more than once.

...and my argument is still that you don't need Jurrah-like 'X Factor' to kick bags.

That said, you've created a tautology in which 'X Factor' covers almost every player who could kick eight goals on a regular basis, so it's now a moot point.

I don't recall saying necessary to have X Factor, I'm pretty sure the word generally has been used in my posts right from the start. For my benefit, can you tell me what post number I said that?

Post #79 (emphasis added):

enough X factor to kick a bag like that...

There was no caveat in this post.

However - as I said in the post that you just quoted (!) - I entered the debate on the assumption that you meant that it was generally necessary, so it's a moot point anyway.

[The Chazz 4,077]

Just when I think it's over...

You're like a monster from a bad horror movie

...and my argument is still that you don't need Jurrah-like 'X Factor' to kick bags.

That said, you've created a tautology in which 'X Factor' covers almost every player who could kick eight goals on a regular basis, so it's now a moot point.

Post #79 (emphasis added):

There was no caveat in this post.

However - as I said in the post that you just quoted (!) - I entered the debate on the assumption that you meant that it was generally necessary, so it's a moot point anyway.

So, in order to fuel your disagreement, you misquoted me. Hope it made you feel superior.

[Rogue 585]

So, in order to fuel your disagreement, you misquoted me. Hope it made you feel superior.

I didn't misquote you.

In case you needed reminding, here's the post again:

Singular bag, no 'generally' caveat, no 'or class' caveat.

EDIT:

You did refer to bags, multiple, in your next post, although in that same post you mentioned Mark le Cras, Kennedy and Riewoldt - all who have only kicked eight or more once.

Furthermore, in later posts you reverted to referring to the ability to kick 'a bag' and 'an 8-goal bag'.

(Surely you could have just looked at your own posts before accusing me of mis-quoting you).

[Guest hangon007]

The Drums are beating! B)

[rpfc 28,267]

The Drums are beating! B)

If you don't supply context we cannot know what you are going on about.

[biggestred 5,016]

jungle drums for baileys head because jurrah hasnt kicked 20 in a game yet.