Its a hard decision, but what Scully decides will dictate what he is thought of for years to come...

Leigh Colbert comes to mind, he wasnt thought of as highly when he left the cats for north...

Something that needs to be remembered is that Melbourne took Jeff White off the Dockers after 2 years, so we have been in a GWS situation before...

Yeah but we (I believe) gave up our number one draft pick for white. If scully (and I hope to hell he doesn't go) leaves, we will not get a number 1 pick for compensation, judging by the ablett to gc deal..

No, I was talking about the Friday night Triple M broadcast. He was confident about Gazza leaving early on, an unlike Hutchy and others, didn't change his mind every week.

Gazza ? What else ?

These kind of journaliists make several predictions every week, they're bound to get one right.

I don't mean to be a stick in the mud, but what is so exciting about this? The headline was a bit sensationalist, and the comment from Trengove amounted to "yeah, I'd love to be a one club player". Every player who has ever played the game has probably said this - until they don't anymore. There was even an "at this point" quote thrown in there!

I already love Jack Trengove - seems a quality bloke and will definitely be a quality player, but this was a nothing article.

Yeah, I thought this response would be the second post in the thread.

I was just trying to pour some water on the Scully-is-leaving let's-organise-a-mass-suicide fire.

Unfortunately to do that, I kinda had to ignore common sense for the greater good.

Fortunately some of our supporters either agreed, or aren't too sharp.

Either way, this calmed the situation a little.

So keep it to yourself Nasher!