Satyriconhome

Humour lost on you? Probably

Mahoney "ok Goody, the plan is to trade out Hogan Kent and Tyson, and trade in May, Kolathingy and Preuss, we haven't any idea or plan going forward as to what the forward line will look like, that ok with you? Goody "sure"

Renewed mine and lady's Trident Home and Away, thanks for the Tax back ScoMo

You mean I actually have my own opinion, nice input to the topic from you, textbook reply? Half the rumours pre Trade Week are manager driven, nothing like driving up the asking price

So what evidence do you have to say May is the answer, his last couple of years? I don't fawn, and if you treat players with respect you can discuss their game with them, perceived faults and all, you want to try it, you may learn something If one of the journos happens to mention we are interested in a player, you can guarantee a topic very quickly on here with posters extolling their virtues as the second coming As the same time denigrating players already on our list Everyone has an opinion, mine is May is overrated, doesn't mean the FD share that opinion

May has been an undisciplined sook for last 2 years, has shown no captain qualities at all, yes he is a good big goriila minder, but please, does he pass the no [censored] test

Correct, unless they find a part time role that suits him, a la Robbo, use his off field personality

Hopefully tongue in cheek

He is not an assistant coach, he is player and coach development, if you must snipe, get it right hero

Click whirrrr click whirr give it a rest Melksham has come to our club and perforned, Milestone of 150 games, Not about you

Exactly

Yes but it was my opinion again, and the Sliane topic has been going for a while and I didn't contribute I know you may find this a staggering concept but some do have differing opinions to the mob rule/group speak/FOBLO unfortunately these days they get hammered down as it is a concept that frightens the masses, the ability to think for oneself

Golden Balls is a nickname given to a gifted player of a ball sport, Beckham used to get it from opposition supporters We are discussing whether in our opinions, which in the big scheme things, don't matter a jot, the club should chase him There are similar topics about other players, Sloane was always going to stay, in my opinion, so didn't join in on that one

Weaknesses identified by who? The experts on here David King I don't deny he gets a bazilllion touches, but it is what he does with them, he goes missing when the heat is on With the three i mentioned all playing well last week, it gave him the opportunity to rack up the touches His inside work has only appeared this year and is inconsistent He reminds me of Priddis with his accumulating but not hurting, how Priddis won a Brownlow still amazes me I have an opinion on every player on the Melbourne list, but there is enough vitriol and denigration of their playing abilities already on this forum As you can see, apart from yourself, the ones who replied are those that require validation, apart from the one that just seems to explode from the excitement these days As I said if the club decides to sign Golden Balls, that's ok with me, I have no say in it

Here's three of the reasons Gaff is looking good this year Shuey Redden Yeo

No opinion is right or wrong, it is an opinion Not sure which bit you don't get You only have to read the game day and post match to see differing opinions on the same player It is only a certain type of person that requires validation that their opinion is the correct one and others are wrong

You should try reading some of your posts over the years Not sure which bit you dont get If the Club signs Gaff, cool, means they have a different opinion on him to me I can live with it, only seems you and some of your ilk can't Gaff had a good game today

The point is their similar repeat posts all over this forum, the denigrating of Tyson being one

Oh so finally I'm allowed an opinion Will support him 100% if he becomes a Melbourne player, if he does, will look fwd to the first game he plays and the Game Day topic

It is an opinion, as I said FD may have completely different one, said if they sign him, not going to sulk, just not a fan

Shares let me, 43000 shareholders?

He hasn't taken it to a new level, he just seems to have because West Coast were skiing downhill, last 3 games back to his accumulating best

I've never rated him, there are others who think the same, unfortunately groupthink and FOBLO takes over, why anything becomes popular Priddis was the same, how he won the Brownlow always staggered me As for the AA team, how Nev Jetta hasn't been in it for last two years says it for me

Thank you, he is an accumulator, let's look at Redden and Shuey for impact or work rate Oh please, so you would say he is better than Oliver, have a lie down chap, you need it I was watching the game, but thank you, never been and never will be impressed by him, he is an accumulator, always has been, always will be, if we sign him, all well and good as the FD have a different opinion to me 9 disposals that did what?