Chris from Perth

i am all over Kamdyn, from what i have seen - seems a clone of RIvers. # 47 Sydney Kamdyn McIntosh Peel Thunder 192cm / 78kg / ‘94 Others will have him a lot higher but having seen a fair bit of him I am still a bit unsure. Seen a few times at champs and also some of his WAFL games and he didnt scream out the Rd 1 prospect I am being told. What is clear to me he is that he is a good key defensive prospect who seems to have good agility and a good understanding of reading the game and influencing it. I think he would be a Heath Grundy type player as seems to go alright on all types. Testing results from DC were very good. Matt Wallis might be another type they would look at

if we want him we will be up against Cats, Bombers & Bulldogs you have to give something to get something dont use early picks, but mid pick PLUS i seriously think 1 of these 3 players will be offered. 1. Tapscott - Adelaide Boy....hard to think we would trade him but depends how highly we rate Boak. 2. Petterd - How does Port rate him? i think he will be at GWS or GC next year anyway 3. Dunn - if he cant keep his spot for rest of year consider him trade bait

for me, Jordie would not be in our very best team you need to have at least 2 strings to your bow............he is just keeping a spot warm for either Taggart or Gysberts imo.

surely one if many Dees fringe players that other clubs will ask about. how does Neeld rate him? part of trade in MIni Draft?

we need to target Victorians at interstate clubs. Jarod Lyons Luke Thompson Aaron Cornelius Ryan Lester on top of this i reckon these 2 would be ideal Matt DE boer Jacob Surjan and any chance we could get Jude Bolton back to VIc?...................

from the games i have sen this year a Big SMokey for me looks like being a backman from WA, who really reminded me of a young Jared RIvers Kamdyn Mcintosh - 188cm, had a great game last night, looks to be cool and composed. my smokey last year was Brandon Ellis and he went at 15, so not sure.

na not for me. i reckon Stef Martin could be as damaging as Trent West with continued game time his athleticism is amazing - he just cant kick! which is an issue - but he could be anything and our fwd line needs to be mobile and trent west is not the man, also - have you given up on Jurrah? our fwd line will hopefully in 2013 consist of Clark,Jurrah, Garland,Martin, Tapscott and NEW SMALL FWD after watching the TOP 30 draft picks go around in last few weeks, i dont think we should be giving a draft pick up.

Wow, surely you have not seen Casey much? Williams is as slow as wet week (atm) and seems to lack intensity at VFL Level and Jack F - is not ready yet lets play Bate as a fwd and see how he goes!!