Lucifers Hero

Mentioned as a hypothetical perhaps but where has MFC's interest been noted or reported?

It seems the AFL have quietly dumped their '3 strikes and out for 6 weeks rule'. At best it looks like out for 2 or 3 weeks or not at all... And has anyone noticed the a whole range of non-injury reasons for players of a number of clubs missing a few games here and there. ...maybe they stop target testing some players after 2 strikes...

The Age is reporting we are interested in Harley: "Melbourne are believed to have shown interest in Fremantle youngster Harley Balic, who is eyeing a move to a Victorian club after two seasons with the Dockers. The 20-year-old spent extended periods on leave from Fremantle this year as he dealt with personal issues. The Demons are remaining tight-lipped on the matter". Who knows how accurate that is! Demons are saying nothing (and I like that). I don't usually try and imagine trades but if the report is true might we trade Kent for him?

Koch may play quite a price for his rant. Appears Hinkley wants to be released from his contract. http://www.theaustralian.com.au/sport/afl/afl-finals-ken-hinkley-wants-out-of-port-adelaide/news-story/b0cfb3e1f1d9ec8afcd75b5f70122a18 It may become a matter for the AFL to resolve and Hinkley to GCS is probably the AFL's only chance of getting GCS off the road to ruin. If it suits them they will make sure he gets there and won't let Port sue him for breach of contract.

On Thursday 9 November 2pm - List Lodgement (2) happens so more players will become available as Delisted Free Agents.

A good time to close thread, perhaps...

Agreed. Plus (career averages): - Doesn't defend nor put pressure on the ball carrier: 1% things (.86 per game). tackles (1.8 per game). contested possessions ( 6 of 25 per game). - Doesn't help the team score: i50 (3.6 per game). goals (.35 per game). goal assists (.52 per game) clearances (2 per game) - Doesn't show signs of being able to defend up forward or in the mid. - Hasn't impacted in finals. In summary, he is not an impact player either offensively nor defensively. Admittedly, he had a good year when he made AA in 2015 but hasn't shown a lot since. I know stats aren't everything but over a long period they do tell a story. Based on his stats and DL's penchant for aggressive, go in hard players, he would become the new DL whipping boy! Being able to run and once a Dees supporter isn't enough to gain my vote.

Can only be Watts. Or ironically, Salem! I think the club knows that bb, which is why I doubt they will be traded. And for mine none of the prospective names being thrown around on DL are such reliable kicks at goal under pressure.

I stopped watching at qtr time after the duckers had 3 dubious free kicks: Selwood faked a hit on the head (resulted in a goal). Dangerfield who dived forward (kicked a point) and another to him for some unknown reason (goal). Even the commentators were saying umpires should pay what they see and not what they think happens to champions. Meanwhile, at the other end Taylor (and sometimes Touy) were blocking Buddy or manhandling him eons before the ball got near them and at one stage Taylor got the free because Buddy jostled him out of the way. Buddy got no protection whatsoever from the umpires. The die was cast in the first 20 minutes and the terrible umpiring gave Geelong all the momentum and the quarter time lead. The final score suggests Sydney were outplayed and outcoached so didn't deserve to win. But that doesn't overcome the umpires' favouritism for certain players and noticeable lack of that for others.

As I said I think it is rubbish and a media beat up based on a random Waldron tweet!

It was during 'The Rush Hour', if that helps.

Brian Waldron puts out a random tweet with nothing to support it!!! Then radio, tv, newspapers are all going on about it. Obviously none of them have contacted the club or else they would say 'melbourne had no comment when contacted'. That alone suggests there is little truth to it. All click bait. Waldron achieved his goal: Keeping his name in the media. I think it is all rubbish. Waldron is a St Kilda supporter and a few weeks ago he said they were interested in Watts. I just hope the club has got around Salem and Watts and told them where they stand. I also hope they both stay.

The club has announced some staff changes. http://www.melbournefc.com.au/news/2017-09-15/jackson-promotes-from-within-club The existing role is now split into Marketing (directed at new stakeholders) and Communications (directed at existing stakeholders). The latter involves the promotion of 'Ryan Larkin to general manager of stakeholder relationships and communications'. “Ryan Larkin has built outstanding relationships in the media and across the club’s key stakeholders in his time at the club. I know this elevation will help to further grow the club’s ability to provide the very best coverage and communications for our club and supporters, along with nurturing the key relationships that are critical for our club’s success.” Ryan was heavily involved in responding to the post rnd 23 backlash to the club so I doubt we will have that communication fiasco again. I applaud PJ in recognising the importance of communication with supporters with a specific general manager position.

Petracca was on Triple mmm yesterday. Some footy items: His Exit meeting: To bring his 2017 disappointment and hunger for next year into pre season and is expected to play more in the midfield next year. Weight not an issue. Endurance and consistent running need to improve for more midfield. Will tag along with Oliver to improve after being asked who he will follow around to get his conditioning right. I reckon that is a good choice given how Oliver's professionalism and preparation have received great praise from the coahces. Mentioned Jones, Viney and Oliver have been invited to the Brownlow. Love that Oliver is invited. On a lighter note: Will be a barrista at Lavazza marquee @ Melbourne Cup. Off to Byron with some mates - get out of Melb for the GF. Then off to the US with Harmes and Tyson and someone else (non football but seemingly well known). Then to the Maldives with his girlfriend. A very engaging young man.

Something has gone terribly wrong with our salary cap management if we need to give up our only silky players to fit in Lever, given we have a $2m windfall (and having Lumumba off our books). Grain of salt needed - make that a kilo!

You misunderstand. I was giving you credit for being on the money.

https://www.foxsports.com.au/afl/adelaide-tells-melbourne-it-wants-two-firstround-draft-picks-for-talented-defender-jake-lever/news-story/dbe7542425f46d6e0852f5b44c034fce From the article: "ADELAIDE ... want two first-round draft picks ...if he seeks a trade back to Victoria". "Some observers, however — and it is safe to say Melbourne will agree — argue that Lever isn’t worth two first-round choices". "Another option ...would be to give up two first round picks and receive a decent pick back, or to give up a first rounder and then swap picks". That is pretty much as @Judd's Granny describes. The article also says that Coll has dropped out of the race. If a trade doesn't involve a third club there is a fair chance it will be done early in the trade period which starts on October 9 (if he decides to come to us). I'm starting to get my hopes up!

If correct, its good to see mfc protecting our 2018 picks (said to be a very good draft vs 2017).

Deleting duplicate post.

It sounds like WB players have had enough. Mitch Wallis was quite forthright last week: "Time will tell, we've all gone our separate ways now so I think the trade period is not for another three or four weeks and there will probably be some conversations which we're pretty well aware of to decide his future...If he decides to stay, he'll stay for a long time. And if he doesn't, well, good luck to him". And there is a bit of chat about players not wanting to play with him: https://www.foxsports.com.au/afl/david-king-and-mark-maclure-say-the-western-bulldogs-have-made-a-strong-call-in-looking-to-trade-jake-stringer/news-story/5bcb11edcae413c88f124851adb3f031 Off field issues aside, if you can't earn your teammates respect there's not much room at a footy club. This has caveat emptor writ large all over it! Luckily mfc have a no d...head policy. Our energies need to be focused on finals not on baby sitting a problem child and putting out spot fires.

Fixed

I was simply guessing D, based on the Italian names on Hawkes list. We need to wait and see what @willmoy can give us.

Are you the new Riddler! Sicily or Puopolo? Rioli even? Yes to Sicily - right age group and can play. No to Puopolo - he is already 30 and is slowing down. Don't need anymore of those. More information please? Or are you just stirring the pot

Effectively delisted. They will not be on the Club's next List Lodgement to the AFL. The only way the club could get something is if waited for a trade or an FA move of Trengove or Spencer. Importantly, by not waiting the club is doing the right thing by the players. Their managers have maximum time to find them a club. It is easier for other clubs to take them as Delisted Free Agents than negotiate a trade.

Looks like Jack may continue in the AFL https://www.foxsports.com.au/afl/dumped-demon-jack-trengove-definitely-wants-to-play-football-again-says-manager-adam-ramanauskas/news-story/bbaefd15e2753113635e4758e2014b44 If he wants to continue hope he gets gig. Will be delighted to see him get another go and continue to play the game he loves.