Lordweaver

No I'm not, I'm with Bonkers who is a lonely voice of reason amongst the many posturing saints, holy men, do gooders and the self righteous who see no middle ground, no reason, no compromise, no sense.

Let's be pragmatic and not throw the baby out with the bath water, if we have a FOJ sponsor waiting in the wings, let's go for it, otherwise stay calm, get an apology and move on.

Hardtack is being racist by referring to me as Einstein, I want him sacked!!

Read my posts Hardtack

"Kill our football club" as if!!!! Some of you guys are worse than the media, in fact alot of you are probably shock jocks in your spare time, god knows U must have alot of spare time.

Yeah let's dump them!! What a great start guys, then let's dump Jurrah for violence, Moloney for Alcohol abuse etc etc

Warren, if your son is disgusted by the comments I'd suggest he must be home schooled..plenty of people use this type of dialogue for banter...unfortunately this guy Polis is a CEO of a major sponsor, not condoning it at all but not too surprised either, I live in the real world. Polis should make a public apology.

I'd settle for an apology, we need the dollars, let's get on with palying footy, the guy is a [censored] but probably reflects a number of CEO's, don't stop supporting Melbourne because of this guy.

can't affford to lose 2 million a year

It won't prove who we are as a club, if you believe that you are mad. They are a top four proposition, we are far from that, we don't yet have the personnel.

Dees by 5 points in what will be an exciting game, expect the Dees to kick out to the same side every bloody time and then bomb it long into a congested forward line, apart from that I think we will win.

Demons by 5 points in a thriller...

How do we know Davey is sooky, cos he can't get the ball? Pretty silly comment, still OUT: Davey, Mc Kenzie IN: Sellar Couch

The Good Winning the contested ball The Bad Too predictable in defence and attack The Ugly Neeld's facial expressions

There's always next week

Too predictable with kickouts, too slow to bring on Bate, why no tag on Black??

Some responsibility has to rest with Neeld who seemed to let the backs kick out to the same side, run the ball along the one side of the boundary and kick to a flooded forward line, add to that the delay in getting Bate on and perhaps not throwing Clark in the ruck and giving Jamar a spell at full forward because both were being beaten in their respective positions.

Yeah drop Davey, Mc kenzie and start Bate in the guts please with couch

warched the third quarter again on foxtel and we were so predictable, kicking out to the same side every time running the ball along the boundary and bombing it in to a congested forward line, add to that the delay in bringing on Bate and I think Neeld has some way to go. I think he is the right guy, love his hard edge, too simplisitic to blame davey green and co though.

That's what will decide his fate in the end, not how he performs in the media.

Interesting that Neeld said that when he was running the collingwood midfield he never had to worry about tagging, well he's got the melbourne midfield and as Roos said he could have got someone to tag Black and follow him to the showers.

I agree Ron, I think he realises what a massive undertaking this is and I think he will be great for us.

That's right Arsene but after tonight on the couch he seemed to be backing away from those earlier comments.

Roos appeared surprised when Neeld said that the decision to appoint the two Jack's was not solely his own final decision.

Matthew's comments could be in part due to some Brisbane Lions baggage, perhaps a bit dirty on Mitch for leaving but it is true that he played better in the ruck and may not be a natural forward.