rjay

We got the wrong Anderson...

If this was in the ruling then I think it's the grounds for appeal...

His set shot kicking is hit or miss unfortunately like a lot of our team. Playing him in defence it appears was a masterstroke as he's been a much more confident player since returning forward.

Boyd found out to his detriment that Kentfield doesn't take any rubbish. Took him a while to get up off the deck.

That's true but you can only do what you can do. AJ is probably next man in. I think Kentfield is really promising but for his development it may be best to leave him a Casey for the rest of this season as he hasn't had any preseason. Happy for him to play if the FD think he's up to it.

AJ had a great game...

I don't think Bailey Laurie's extension is causing us a lot of grief at the moment but I get your point. I think a lot on here thought and still think we had a list that should have led to more flags. A dynasty... Personally I've always thought we got the most from that list to win in 2021 but had some big holes in it that needed to be addressed. The point about the professionals rings true to me and I fear they may have misjudged the list as many of the amateurs here have. I think our biggest issue was off the ground and the transition of power away from PJ...a lot of time was taken up with internal struggles and peripheral issues, the eye seemed to be off the ball so as to speak. Time will tell but some decisions as you say don't look that great. With better oversight and more focus maybe we would have been in a better position... but that we will never know.

The trouble is that it's easy to look in hindsight.

Tom Morris would definitely be my go to list management expert...

...but it's May. Lets say it was Darcy Moore in the same position. The whole football world would say it was a football act and he was going for the ball. May is not Moore and it's doubtful that he gets a fair hearing.

Umpires - I don't know Umpires - Not the difference (maybe) Umpires - Back to 3 Umpires - Some leadership needed The Game - In poor shape Umpires - Top down problem Umpires - AFL & mirrors Umpires - I don't know

I don't really believe this part... ...but agree on the umpiring.

Doesn't sound like it going by the above 'dazz'...

Goody bashing...

Depends what you are calling the modern era?

I would put Hassa and Hardeman in personally...

Unfortunately this seems to be the case in all walks of life these days. The nuance is gone.

KK thinks he's no good. I think you're a much better judge 'Jaded'...

I think it was Barassi who said something along the lines of, in any team you will have a group of happy players, a group of unhappy players and a group of undecided players. The art of coaching is to keep the unhappy players away from the undecided players.

I've always found (at least 90% of the time) when people say it's a good listen what they really mean is these guys agree with my thinking...

If you look at his list there's a fair case to say he is underperforming...

Sorry 'Wayne', I'm not on the origin bandwagon. The ultimate in our game is club football & that's how it should stay.

That we will never know...

So late to the party on this thread Tim...sorry. I know you've been battling over the last few years but hadn't seen this. Just wish you all the best mate, it's an incredible fight and to see it documented like this is quite special. Your resilience is inspiring. I'm looking forward to seeing some video and pix from your August gig.