BIG JIM

Im very sure GWS and GC will not bid for jack given the top end talent they risk.Im sure the MFC will call there bluff and say thanks for whitfield or toumpas. After tonight i think Jack is maybe pick 5 but not in the class of Toumpas and whitfield. Yes i think todd listen to me and told his boy to just crusie through the carnival.

I did not no till today that anyone thought this kid would go number 1.GWS must bid for him with sheedy at the helm

The ox said on sen that Joe is the clear number 1 pick if essendon did not get the F/S bid. So my question is will GWS just bid on him not viney or can they bid for both.

There is no way richmond can think the media will buy this crap

I have to say i thought it was going to be a thread about something the blues are doing with beyond blue. Change the headline. Mods

Me thinks the AFL will be knocking on Dustin martins door for a random drug test?

Im getting on the dees this week $5 sounds nice to me. I still dont rate this team that high. We were well in front of richmond 12 months ago. Looks like cousins had a big effect on dustin. Great role model old ben.

We could do with Dan connors if we can get him help.

Yes i just cant see us wasting a top 5 pick on a ruck fullstop. We need mids and more mids i feel you can find ruck in the VFL or later in the draft.We might use our 2nd rnd on a small forward as i feel this is something we need now but our rucks are stronger then alot of other clubs so we will not go for a ruck this year. I think we could well go for a stringer as we seem to still need that Hurley type up and around the forward 50 and this kid can go through the middle also. My thinking is that we will go for toumpas and stringer but if one of these boys are gone it will be wines.

I am starting to think GWS will not dummy bid for viney as they will gain nothing but risk the chance of missing whitfield or toumpas even grundy I also think that if sheedy would love to screw someone it may be his old club and they might bid for Joe before our boy GC will not bid on Viney with pick 1

I want this kid Toumpas and Stringer

I have seen him play and i rate him the 2nd best kid in this draft after whitfield and if you listen to any expert they would rate jack as about the 3rd best.

I am sick of thinking about this it's simple jack is worth pick 3 and we have pick 3. The good thing is that we have pick 4 to get another mid Toumpas And we have pick 12 or 13 which should net us Boak in a super draft. All of this power get the MFC a new Midfield Jamar,Jones,Boak,Viney,Toumpas We win its that simple.

Poor from mate Jack watts bashing again give it a rest.Jack watts is in the top 3 players at our club in the last 5 weeks. But guys like you cant help yourself. Everything at the MFC is jack watts fault. lol

Yes i can see what your saying but for now it's great to see Jack just getting run into his legs. Jack has got alot of upside in him and i rate this guy right up there. He reads the play very well and has played 3 games in his life as an AFL mid. Jack is the last problem at the MFC and to say he cant be elite is wrong.

I love this kind of thinking well done.

I say we use the picks 3,4 in the super draft and all other picks are to trade in for a Beams or wellingham or boak. We are in a great postion to attack this FA and should move heaven and earth to fix our midfield so we can be the next westcoast. I still think we have a strong 10 players on our current list that we can build a strong side around. Trengove,Jones,frawley,Blease,Gysberts,Jamar,Grimes,Clark,Watts,Jurruh If we can add 6 strong names to that list in 2013 Viney,Boak,Toumpas,Stringer,Wellingham,Knights We could be playing finals in 2013 and having a real crack

I think if MFC are going like this next year We will see Neil craig back coaching and im sure that Neil would love another chance. Im not saying i want Neeld to fail. Im just saying i want the MFC to win games. If there was no GWS or GC we would still be the worst team in the AFL after 5 years of Draft picks. Neeld has done some great talking but were still waiting for the results and i dont see them coming.

I would be very angry if anyone from board level has been in Marks ear. Im sure its just we suck.

We could delist about 12 players easy from this MFC team. You just cant carry this many spuds at this level. We are in some real trouble if we dont make finals next year IMO 6 years with no finals is just shocking after the picks we have had. This draft is going to give this club one last chance with this list. Mark neeld has a big job coming up and i am sure he will show no mercey as this is his once in a life time shot as coach. I think there will be one or two big name moved on at years end. I have a bad feeling that blease will not be with the dees in 2013. Im sick of looking forward to draft picks. Cant wait for the day i just go to the footy and know my team has a chance to win every week again. Its been a long hard 6 years for every demon fan.Its time for the MFC to do something for its loyal fans. just bloody start winning Melbourne

It's hard to watch your team get smashed by a team of spuds. What does that make us?

Just calling it as i see it

Magner,Bate,Nicholson,Dunn,Bail.Spencer,Moloney There is 7 names from this game alone on our list who are not at AFL level and should be moved on.

I have got to say that when i seen Jamar and Jones out that was the first thing that come to my mind.This is hard to watch so many players that need to go.

GWS will not take the risk if MFC pick up the phone. T.Viney: Hi kevin you little toss bag Todd viney here Jack's dad. K.Sheedy:OHHH hi Todd how can i help. T.Viney: I am just calling to tell you i will break both your legs and jam that big ugly head were it dont fit if you bid on my boy. K.Sheedy: UMMM im sorry todd gubby said it not me. T.Viney:Fix it Kevin. Now. K.Sheedy:Sorry for the trouble todd it will not happen again. T.Viney: Good and send my love to Tom BEEP BEEP.