Very Jaded

Actually you can thank the concrete dump that is Marvel for that. He landed badly and hurt his foot. Nobody did anything unusual to him and he would do the same motion 100 times a season at the G. His season is definitely over. His career might be too, as many players never come back from this injury.

Gawn aside, Thursday's team was the best we have fielded all year. Rolling into finals we will do our outmost to keep the side really settled with minimal changes, injuries aside of course. I can't see us doing anything radical now, other than obviously bringing Gawn back, and potentially making the call on Hunt vs Bowey and deciding on whether we keep Weideman in and drop Bedford or continue to pursue a small forwardline strategy once Gawn is back.

Please see my comment above. I was responding to the poster complaining that Majak didn’t do this earlier so we could pick someone up on the mid season draft. I have nothing but respect for Majak and what he’s overcome.

What? No I meant he clearly wasn’t injured or contemplating retirement prior to the mid season draft. I was responding to the assertion that he should have done this beforehand.

Ben Brown is very sad.

He clearly wasn’t injured and contemplating retirement. It’s more unfortunate that we didn’t get Tmac’s diagnosis a few days earlier as he could have gone on the long term injury list. Anyway wishing Majak all the very best in the future.

He came with plenty of baggage. Geelong is a great place for him culturally to go and get the most out of himself.

Scott went on and on about what a good guy Stewart is and not once did he say "we all hope Prestia is ok". Shows you exactly what kind of club Geelong is. Putrid. You want to see remorse? Have a look at Chandler's reaction to his tackle. He was almost in tears and he reached out to the opponent to check he was ok. That is true remorse for a far less intentional act!

Anyone who can’t see that this guy is a once in a generation unicorn is kidding themselves.

Viney is a big game player. Thrives in finals and when the heat is on. It’s why he’s so valuable.

Best midfield game we’ve played all year. Not having Gawn there forced us to read the tap, be less predicable and lower our eyes going forward. Could be a blessing in disguise. But I want him back ASAP.

No change

He seems happy. The crowd gave him so much love. Goody was beaming when he came off and Jackson was smiling from ear to ear. If he leaves I’m comfortable that we’ve done our best by him and I’ll always thank him for that third quarter…

We are back baby. Viney with a captains game. Lever looking like he has two operational feet back. Jackson is beyond words. Sensational performance against big big men. Clarry is just Clarry. Trac back to his best. Love that for us.

Just goes to show how much we need to try and keep him. He is a superstar at 20.

Jackson is immense.

Why oh why can’t we kick for goal

FMD May is having a stinker.

I honestly just want to see the Melbourne DNA back on display tonight. We've looked a million miles off our usual effort and spread the last month. I hope tonight we are back at it. Even if we lose, at least it will signal to me that we are back in the hunt.

If anyone votes Geelong they deserve a ban

Yes the coach confirmed he hasn't recovered from his hamstring on time. Big out for them.

No Zorko somewhat softens the blow of no Gawn.

The pre GF bye probably meant May plays on the day, keeps Naughton to naught and we win by 74 points... just saying.

I’m confused how May isn’t in there. Maybe he lost points for decking Melksham. Not in play.

Having ADHD doesn’t make you a moron or a jerk. It does make you impulsive and reduces your ability to understand consequences. Still a poor excuse.