durango

List Size

For 2013, all clubs (*except Gold Coast and GWS Giants) now operate under the following list sizes.

* Gold Coast Suns: Primary List 42; Rookie List 9
* GWS Giants: Primary List 44-50; Rookie List 9
 

This is from the AFL web site melbourne have 40 on the main list and 4 rookies unless stefan has not played AFL for at least 3 years in any form then he is eligible for the rookie B list otherwise there is no room.

Some judges have him at selection 22 are they right?

If so we did well at 36 to get him we have to back our Football Department who will never get it right 100% of the time.

The Football Department will always have a comparisons like Parish / Oliver and Curnow /Weideman where their judgement is dependent on who has the final say in the selection?

Probably 30 years ago a player who was less than 178 cm (5 foot 10 inches) and less than 78 kg would not get a look in at AFL clubs because they were considered to be too small but last 2 years the mindset has changed by coaches and smaller players who put on tackle pressure and dispose of the ball well have become the norm not the exception.  Both Richmond and Western Bulldogs have created the current trend with smaller quick players playing a roll in the forward line where tackling pressure has allow the ball to remain in the forward half putting pressure on the defenders to make mistakes which result in scoring opportunities.

I am not saying Spargo will make it or not but the Football Department has selected him and we should back their judgement for the time being before criticizing them.

If you were told that Charlie Spargo was a top 5 - 10 selection before you knew how tall he was you would compliment the Football Department on their astute selection.

"We got who we wanted" means "Player we expect to get at that pick was gone"

Smith will be upgraded with a pick 64 beyond 47 which we still have.  We will be drafting 4 players along with Smith.

I know this is my 4th attempt but is Q6 Lynden Dunn

Q3 Clayton Oliver

Q4 Simon Buckly

Darren Jolly

I think if MFC was going to recruit a delisted free agent it would have done it by now?

For 2013, all clubs (*except Gold Coast and GWS Giants) now operate under the following list sizes.

* Gold Coast Suns: Primary List 42; Rookie List 9
* GWS Giants: Primary List 44-50; Rookie List 9
 

So that all arguments re-list sizes I have extracted the above from the AFL web site the Suns and Giants now operate under the same rules as all the other AFL teams?

There's 36 on the list now including Smith. Plus 4 draft picks makes 40. Plus 4 Rookies makes 44. Yes we will be able to recruit 3 Category B rookies. If a player has played a sport other than Australian Rules in the last 3 years then they are eligible to be listed on the Category B rookies list like the international converts and basketball players but category B players cannot play unless a player on the main list is placed on the Long Term Injury list. Whereas 1 Category A rookies can be nominated after round 11.

Yes you can have 6 category A rookies if the main list is 38, the total of the main list and rookies cannot exceed 44.

Thus if Melbourne uses only 3 picks the it can pick a category A rookie.

Maybe he was told that he wont be on the list next year and was going through the motions of playing. I know that some players become despondent when they are told they are not required the effort and energy is sapped by the emotion.

I remember when I was a young man and informed by a VFL club that I was too small and the effect it has has on you. 

If the sample of the highlights are the best of Petruccelle then the AFL should have not extracted them for they are not very flattering.

Never the less they are now out there and if Viney, Taylor and Co are interested then he may be a slider because of the highlights.

The picture of Seb's build is similar to Jack Viney before he was drafted via the father and son, I read the article and I believe he is 182cm at the combine so he has the size and the pedigree to make a good footballer.  The only question is he able to go from school/U18 football to AFL. I would draft him if the choice came down to 2 players (he and another).

I think T Viney and/or Taylor should talk to Jordan Lewis and get his opinion whether to get him as DFA ?

Smith is Cat B Rookie

Melbourne has no rookie positions available since they will be using it for Maynard elevating him from rookie B list to the rookie A list 

I think Clayton Oliver is better than Greg Healy should be in that team along with Michael Hibberd who is much better than Graeme Yeats

It seems when every we make a trade all the geniuses on this site speculate we have paid over the last 3 were Melksham Hibberd and Lever. Hopefully the later will produce a season as good if not better than the other 2.

Just watched Jake Lever Highlights his reading of the play is well above average and is marking is virtually one grab, not much seen re-disposal and run?

I spent 35 years in the field of athletics and have no knowledge of a athlete trained by David Mission.  I believe David is doing the job as he did for the Swans and St Kilda but the football played a decade ago has changed and the current version needs a different fitness set.

I believe that David has run his race and a more modern fitness person should be put in charge, we have that person on staff his name is Daniel Cross.

I have always said only one statistic counts the scoreboard at the end of the match and all other statistics are rubbish

21 hours ago, Deestroy All said:

Riiight. 

Let's see a steeple chaser hit Nathan Jones at full speed and see if he moves a millimetre. 

Apples and oranges. 

By the way Blicavs was a steeple chaser

You do realise the world record for 3k Steeple chase for women is 8:52:78 so 9:45 is not that great for a professional footballer who is an endurance runner. And running and jumping steeples and a water jump is much harder than flat running.  When I was a junior I ran 1 mile(1616 meters) on grass in bare feet in the time of 5:05 which was not that great. I did not train every day. My son who was a decathlete ran 1500 meters after doing 10 events in 2 days in the time of 4:35 he was mainly a sprinter.