Moonshadow

Thought they've been generally poor overall, despite the numerous rule changes and clarifications

Are Tmac and Tracc playing or even on the ground....

Yes, but wasn't that a bucks night bus? No wonder!

And that, my friend, is what's called "flush". The degree to which force was applied is irrelevant to my original post in this chain. See ya.

You're right mono. I'm ashamed. ?

Do tbey all play the same position? Team balence.

I disagree. Watch the video Daisy, the point of May's shoulder hit Berry on the front of his chin, that would be 'flush'. His head tilted back and he played no further part on the game. Revoldt played on. Had Berry been "out cold", May might well have got 3-4 weeks. He has history with the bump. Not sure Jones does.

Roaming Bwyan is more pathetic this year than in 2018.

How good is it not to see a swarm of team runners on the ground zoning?

How the he'll was that a free to Duckwood?

Did you read that in a tweet?

And here's the full narrative by an eye witness. Doubt you'll be pleased with it. https://www.theage.com.au/sport/he-went-berserk-how-vicious-mcg-brawl-started-with-free-kick-decision-20190322-p516qg.html

May's shoulder hit Berry flush on the chin. To me it looked like Liam Jones hit Rievoldt's body and winded him badly One was head and one was body. That's the difference. (But I still think May's should have been a fine only)

Nothing hypothetical, it's a fact. The Richmond fan punched the guy to the ground and then stood over him and continued smashing him while he looked to be unresonsive. Then turned and started punching into other people. Absolutely lost control. If there was more before the footage which he thought was wrong, he should have called for security. Stop condoning violence, Smokey.

I always thought $cully leaving was more to do with SC relief for GWS than the trade deal

Wise, a "hypothetical" is much the same as "considering", which is what I wrote. I'm not sure the club wanted to support Hogan any further. If the numerous reports circulating are true, our club was instrumental in moving him on and not unhappy with the so-called 'unders' we got in the trade, ie, one 1st rounder. I hope he gets back on track, as any normal human would hope. Mental health and addiction are big issues in society. But I do not know him or his family, so forgive me if i care little, particularly of his thoughts on our club. We would benefit from being more foccussed on the MFC moving on. I'm pleased that another club must deal with Hogan's issues and congratulate Mahoney and co who orchestrated the trade.

What? People are considering Hogan be traded back to us??? Are you people mad. Both sides have made their decisions. Let us dry our eyes and get over it. Much bigger fish to fry.

If we think that's bad, Essendrug played Joe Daniher 3 times in 11 days early last year. He missed the rest of the season with OP. Has a history of it. Idiots.

Sliding doors on AFL site:

Once Tom Lynch finds his mojo he will be a super star. That is, assuming he can stay on the park

Rance knee. After a falcon mark attempt

Thanks for that Jezza

Jeez, as bad as Carlton look, the umps have been very generous to Richmond

Highly doubt Preuss will play. Weid will give Gawn a chop out.