binman

Well that wasn't the choice (i wasn't arguing that we should not take Kennedy if available) however to answer your question yes.

As much as it would have been great to get Kennedy i have to say i like the idea of getting an untried talent to the club. Hopefully we'll find a future star (which would be a nice change) but even with all the testing and analysis there remains a large element of luck in choosing which 18 year old kid will become a Fyfe or a Dangerfield (and of course development comes into it, which i hope we will better at now than in years past). Its like a gamble and i love a gamble. With skill in selecting and a bit of luck we might get a young gun to develop alongside of Hogan, Toumpas and Viney.

And further, despite the vitriol he received for leaving it appears now in hindsight that the his alleged misgivings about the culture and player development systems were spot on.

That's better finally a rumour on the trade/draft rumour mill thread

NSC, thanks for the goodish oil. Has your source heard anything about Black coming to the dees as an assistant coach?

Yes, good point. The Roos game plan is based on having 8-10 strong bodies mids who can play through the middle but also off the half back and half forward flanks. Indeed this has become the norm in the AFL. Roos was impressed by the size of the freo mid field in his commentary and i suspect he will try to build something similar. Looking at that list above they're all pretty solid guys. Add Watts to the list above (most likely as an outside mid/wing) as Watts has said that Roos has indicated that's where he'll play. Also add Matt Jones who will be much stronger next season and i reckon has all the hallmarks of a player Roos will love. You have to include McKenzie as well as i'm sure he will be our tagger in the middle (and told not to kick!). I think though he'll play Grimes down back. I forget who suggested on it DL (and was roundly howled down) but i agree that Roos might occasionally run Dunn through the center and crazy as it might seem i agree that if Pedo can get fitter there is a chance he may get some time in the middle coming of the hb. I can also see occasions where a Gawn or Spencer is rucking but a Fitzpatrick or Clark start in the center as well (in the same way that at several center bounces in the grand final the hawks had Roughhead in the center with Bailey or Hale doing the ruck work). I harbour dreams of Jetta running through the middle and i think Bail, Kent and Evans can take their turn as perhaps even Howe at times (though i think he will be a high half forward in the main). Tappscott, with his build should be a mid/half forward but i suspect Roos will trade him. If he doesn't trade him this year he will next year if Tappy doesn't take a step up. I hope we get Vince and another good mid with the number 9 pick. Our mid field has been woeful but so has our basic disposal skills. With Tyson, Michie, Toump, Watts and Vince all being good kicks we will be much improved in our ability to maintain possession and to hit targets into what will be a genuinely dangerous forward line. Some success this year is a absolutely crucial and because of this although i hate the idea of losing a possible champ in Kelly or Aish taking Tyson is the prudent move, particularity if the recruiting guys can earn their money by picking a gem at 9. With a much better mid field and better skills we will obviously be much more competitive given how crucial these elements are. Roos understands that we simply have to win some games of footy and be competitive in those we don't. If we can achieve that we will be a much more attractive option fro players next season and will not have to trade our top pick. Oh oh i can feel a bout of Pollyanna syndrome coming on!

Channeling your inner BH BB?

I think Neeld was run over by the reality bus

An excellent point McQueen, particularly in regard to the dons as its not just next season they have to be concerned with. If they don't get some good young players in the next two drafts they will struggle in 4-5 years with the sort of gap in decent players that the dees managed with no draft restrictions

Oh to have a mid field that a decent player struggles to get into!

Would love to see how Col goes under Lyon, with his players needing to super disciplined. Lyon is the Colonel Kurtz of the AFL - Sylvia might be Captain Willard.

I thought it was my wi fi at home but my mobile is super slow at home (i'm on Telstra) but weirdly if i turn wi fi off it is faster

The Swans will have the second best forward line in the league

The AFL will be mortified if Buddy does not end up at GWS. They desperately need him there to help GWS get some traction. One assumes he won't be getting any money from the AFL to be an ambassador. Kudos to Sydney if true but bad for the competition. It is in all clubs interests, especially clubs like MFC and Dogs, that GWS is a success and start winning some games.

Just noted your sig RM. Has Neeld's contract ended and if so can we judge him now?

Martin to Essendon? The mind boggles at the unlimited potential for drug related jokes

Who? Phat Phil or DM?

Great dog house! Maybe the club should buy it for Daniel Cross

I'm with Ben Hur on Howe. A keeper. The argument that he is lazy has some validity but we can not afford to lose players as talented as Howe. The excitment he provides for fans should not be dismissed either. He has been a rare bright light. Just as i argued that Watts has suffered from being at the club in a period of complete chaos the same argument holds for Howe (and others like Blease, Tapscott, Strauss et al). Of course professional players have to work hard etc but it is ridiculous to expect players will be able to play to their potential in an environment that is destabilizing - and that's without factoring a poor leadership culture. Lets see how he goes under Roos. I would expect we'll see him address his deficiencies and reach his potential. In terms of position i like him as a forward with occasional runs in the center. As someone notes above with Hogan, Dawes and Clark opposition sides will struggle to match up on Howe and he provides a great foil to those big guys. HAs well as being a great mark he is also pretty good when the ball hits the ground. But yes he needs to increase his pressure.

Would only fly if they land franklin i would have thought, though i guess he has to recover from a serious knee injury

I prefer roos coloured glasses

....ever

What...

I agree Jumbo. I also think it is relevant that for Watts and all the other young players not only have they had Neeld and Bailey (who i actually thought could coach but was hamstrung by off field craziness) it has also been absolute chaos at the club in the last decade. Drama after drama, axings, upheavals, Jimmy's death, tanking investigation, hopeless fd and admin etc etc Its been frustrating for fans - imagine how hard it must have been be for young players to focus on their footy, adjust to AFL and actually develop and improve. The relief in the Watts interview on the MFC is palpable (ie that we have PJ and a clear focus). Signing for 3 years is a great show of faith by both the club and Watts

Not for me. Fantastic news and i'm super positive that he will fulfill his potential and be our best player