Everything posted by Demon17
-
Tom McDonald Re-Signs for 4 Years
Can someone put up a link to this. It was insightful and amusing at the same time. Garry Lyon nearly"... fell off his bike..." when he heard the new yesterday, so happy was he!
-
Slobbo's Mid Year All Australian
Correct. Close this thread for irrelevancy. It about New Ltd. causing outrage so we all talk about them. Lets deny our oxygen. And of course Grundy is in - he's Collingwood, the papers main reading audience to whom this team is targeted .
-
Tom McDonald Re-Signs for 4 Years
Rounds out the vision nicely. Good work and highly believable.
-
Peter Jackson's Replacement?
Chairman Glenn Bartlett is former Managing Partner of Australia toughest Tier 1 legal firm Clayton Utz. I reckon he'll have Gill covered.
-
Tom McDonald Re-Signs for 4 Years
Bif day for the marketing Dept. AND the recruiting team. The sales pitch now to Gaff, Wines or anyone else of quality can be: "... how would you like to kick the ball into a Hogan/TMac forward line..." Sign here!
-
Give us some credit! (Media reaction merged thread)
Give him a break. Kane Cornes tips Dees for the premiership and re-confirmed last Friday again before the dogs game on his SEN show.
-
Changes v Collingwood
No-one seems to be talking about Joel Smith lately in these threads. Can anyone advise thoughts on him as an option?
-
Jake Lever injury - Confirmed ACL
Success in converting strong inside 50's into winning sores coincided with lots of things, but primarily T Mac coming back, with huge flwo on effects on Hogan, and mids who finally had targets, but Lever was important also. However his replacement will merge into the best defence in the league - Hibberd, Jetta Salem, Lewis and OMac. Plus a top line midfield that helps protect them. I would be more mortified in losing Gawn, T mac Hogan , Viney, Oliver, Brayshaw,, Jones........... Just the debate on here about Lever' s replacement has thrown up 4 or 5 options. For any of the above there is no-one capable of filling any of these shoes in tersm of quality. QB will tell though
-
Dom Tyson
Correct. Enough was enough for goodwin.
-
Round 11 Non-MFC Games
Brilliant first paragraph lt. The fawning by darcy at the post match was sickening. Empty vessel commentator so common on ch 7 ( excl daisy who seems smarter than all of them)
-
My 3 word player analysis V Bulldogs
In the spirit of trying to rationalize levers loss i have gone over joeboys above list which i thinl is a great summary of all snd counted 15 names i would be equally devastated to lose. Once upon a time that numbet might have been 5 ish. If goodwin can fill tjis loss adequately recognising levers value may not be replicated i think the fundamentals are still sound. Q B will tell us.
-
Changes v Collingwood
Completely agree.. Again on todays game spargo showed he's made this position his own. Lowers his eyes . Chases. Beautiful kick. Hard runner. Mature beyond his years in a tight spot. Doesn't panic. Lets all move on.
-
Clarry "one of the best to emerge in last 20 years"
As the great John McEnroe said: "...you cannot be serious.." Do you understand the various leadership qualiites? Such as " follow me" as a prime example, train hard, play hard, look how I play ... etc.
-
Clarry "one of the best to emerge in last 20 years"
Its interesting that from the start he's had a lot to say on the field at set up time, prior to centre bounce etc. , contributing to the disicussions with Jones, Gawn, Viney. He was very vocal yesterday. Just feels like a leader and belongs in the engine room. He said a few weeks ago his re-signing was a "..no brainer..." He's part of the scariest demon midfield Iv'e seen (since 1967)
-
Give us some credit! (Media reaction merged thread)
Be accurate and in context: He said: "..Not convinced just yet. Going very very well but not getting carried away. THE in form team and the way they win has been impressive..." . "... Roos did exactly what he was paid to do..." "... Lever absolutely superb..." "...a successful and seamless succession plan..." Darcy, Brown, McClure and Taylor say unselfish, modest, balanaced and can win the flag. Reasonable assessment by the Duck. He has consistently been upbeat this year. Who cares anyway - i bet Goodwin doesn't.
-
Wallace Urges Adelaide to Target Lever
That they were thinking about Lever means lost focus on real issues of game plan, structures etc. Lever's first contested win occurred in the first 5 minutes and set the pattern. Unproductive and displays lack of recogntion this is a professional game and they still have the Adelaide inferiority complex. As Morpheous in the Matrix says, they are an ' artificail construct' , not a real team like Port Adelaide or Freo. You want a career? - leave Adelaide and come to the east coast is the standard saying ex-Adelaide people say to me.
-
Changes vs Bulldogs
It should be considerreed for many of the younger players, esp. Spargo, that they need the experienece of Queens Birthday to prepare for finals atmosphere. Resting him this week is counter productive in this regard unless he's injured. 80,000 crowd possibly and they need to be prepared for a big stage. I have great faith in medical team. If he plays he will be OK to play and not a risk.
-
Tom McDonald sent for Scans (24/5)
No it didnt. Appalling effort it final game and inability to kill a side for% cost the finals. Viney did his own thing in an effort to get back early when he was advised that 9 weeks off was needed. Look what happened. Gawn jones and watts were all effectively managed. Tmac and the team have done the right thing all along this year.
-
Wallace Urges Adelaide to Target Lever
Was the catalyst for the afl to commence trial by video. Lever was ably backed up last week when carlton tried it on in the 3rd quarter. Esp by tmac and hibberd. Will the crows seriously risk antogonising viney and lewis? As viney said this week when asked about this and alice springs ".....I'm ready to rumble...."
-
Tom McDonald sent for Scans (24/5)
Impeccable sources told me T Mac was absolutely focused on the correct rehab this year. He would call relevant staff every day in some cases to get their sign off for something he may have been thinking of doing, foot conditions status etc. Thus his comeback has been first rate (as opposed to how jack sought to come back early) This is another good example IMO of TMac simply being professional, sensing a concern and having it checked out.
-
MATCH PREVIEW AND TEAM SELECTION - Round 10
You'e summarised well the likely post - match "narrative" (I love that word) If we lose it will be they were undermanned, we're at full strength and failed - I can see the headline now. or, if we win , they were undermanned and we should have anyway. A ho-hum/didn't mean much headline Then the media will be saying it wasn't really the test and start looking for another upcoming matching to declare that WILL be the test. In summary, can't win either way and just get the 4 points and move on and the club just ignores the external white noise as I suspect they are doing now.
-
What Champion Data Think
Plus: 3. Must keep Viney healthy 4. 5 teams can win the flag - Melbourne is one of them 5. Outstanding coaching and confidence in trying new things. Expect something different pre-finals, if make it 6. Jake Melksham just needs nothing to think about and let him play on auto pilot 7. No. 1 pressure acts and contested possession team. No easy games for opposition 8. Oliver operating at another/higher level from last year
-
What Champion Data Think
Some key messages from the Champion Data boys on SEN this morning for interest. 1. The last 4 rounds have yielded 4 wins and a % of 198% - the last time this occurred was rounds 10 to 13 - 1964 2.Will finish top 4
- Post Match Discussion - Round 9
-
14 Quarters in a Row
The team has now won 14 quarters in a row. Does this mean anything given the opposition, or does it actually hint at the end of the narrative that we struggle against lower, ' gimme' , sides, and its full team ahead in these types of games the supporters up to now are always fearful the team will struggle in?