old dee

Correct but I still believe you need to consider that element before we put him into one of the biggest games of the year. One hell of a step up from Preston at the bottom of the vfl to Collingwood at the G.

I will be surprised if Brown plays and I expect Sam to play. Put simply there is no one else. JVR played well but against the worst team in comp.

Spot on layzie. It is not just goals it is the contribution he makes to breaking up the opposition defence.

Yes but we also lost to the Cats and dogs. IMO you cannot simply rely on the backs to win you games in finals. The KPF's have to contribute way more than they have in the last couple of months. Finals are a different ball game. you just cannot afford to carry passengers.

There is no doubt IMO that we will finish in the top four however I find it difficult to believe we can win the flag this year with the poor state of our KPF's. With Tmac out for probably the rest of this year we are left with Brown and Weideman. Brown is way below his best and enough has been said about Sam. We would need Brown to show form he has not shown all year. I see a prelim loss on the horizon.

Not sure what that says about your sex life pf!

Oh I love it, my brother barracks for the Lions.

That is the most insightful thing said this week.

North playing Essendrug at 4.40 on a Sunday and no body cares. How often were we in that situation.

IMO rpfc I don't see us winning the flag with the current forward line unless a miracle happens and we get back Tmac in firing form after being out for weeks with foot problems. Replacing Sam with Brown wont make a lot of difference.

Unless there are injuries I think no change. If Brown is fit perhaps he comes in. At the moment this is as good as it gets. After watching the seconds yesterday Smith needs another week at Casey but of course there is no game next week for Casey ( what crap). I have not forgotten JVR I just think management want him to put in a season at Casey. Yesterday he played the bottom team so his 5 goals should be viewed with a little caution.

I have been one of his critics since early on. However it is now plainly obvious that he is not a senior level talent it is time to stop the bulling and shaming on here. Sam would appear to be a nice guy and I am sure he is trying his best. It is unfortunately not enough. I feel sorry for him. Let's get off his back.

Another bye next week, what a joke this competition is. So they all sit on their hands three weeks from the finals.

Don't read too much into today. The bull ants are last in the comp. A bit like a few weeks ago against North.

Who would want him CBF? Honestly he is not an AFL player.

I think you might have been able to blame that in the past but not during Sam's time.

You are firmly in the .0001 camp!

I think you are spot on there PSD. Any local footy watching today?

I think the money is one thing but I think the going home is bigger.

Or don't read the thread.

The danger in that is the big money may not be available.

Almost perfect Joeboy. I love reading your work. First thread I go to after a game.

You got in one Smokey.

If we needed any further proof that Angus is the one we needed to get signed up it was last night. I was smiling all night.

He will be next week pf.