old dee

It is a fan site people give their opinions take it or leave it. I would be extremely surprised if players come on here. I don't have a high opinion of the average footballer but I reckon most are way more clever than to bother coming on here.

So we are not allow to discuss the a hypothetical Wiseblood? Does every discussion have to based on a fact before it is allowing. There are lots of discussions on here that I don't see any interest in so I don't bother with them. Others should perhaps do similar.

The most sane comment in a long time. Thank you ManDee.

I just don't think he is so good that you would consider an offer bb.

Why lock yourself out of a good deal Nasher. We are talking sumantics on this thread anyway but I don't believe Hogan falls into that group of " not tradeable" He is a good player but not in the top 50 league wise so all options are available.

Your problem is Mr Shadow you are too logical!

What if a better one was available?

Seriously that is the best you can muster when trying to crawl out of your predicament? Shame Jack Shame

In 2017 most of our wins were without him. While that is not the case this year we have won two from two against top eight sides without him. Room for thought.

Your opinion is all I need.

Keep up the good work Mr. leg your talent knows no limits.

In fact quite the reverse!

Banana pancakes with my GD for breakfast this morning. If there is a better way to start a Saturday I don't know it.

And may your run continue

There is only one protocol Dof. And you have not broken it!

It is never on the rails Dof.

Glad to hear it Mr Leg, keep up the good work.

You have my vote bb

Got what I asked for, he created a contest and while not the greatest game ever he was good enough to keep the defence honest and should play next week.

The world has gone to hell in a hand basket Mr. Leg.

And?

ET do you really think we stand a chance against a couple of desperate clubs plus the Weagles?

Forget Gaff he is going to North or staying in Perth. We are the poor cousins in this chase.

Just give us a reasonable game that makes the defence respect you are out there. In the past they have had no respect and played off you knowing you won't embarrass them. Embarrass a few on Sunday Sam and I will be very happy.

He has had a couple against teams like Coburg who are hardly even VFL standard. In recent weeks he has performed a little better but hardly knocking the door down for selection at senior level. He should be allowed to play out this year at Casey which will include a finals series. IMO he will learn more from that than getting a drubbing in Perth. Lets see what he looks like after another preseason in 2019.