DeeSpencer

It’s not unreasonable to say results were often worse with the new game plan than the old one. But the evidence from 22, 23 and even 24 (port, GWS games) was that it was falling short against quality opponents. Plus it was hurting crowds and I even think hurting players - both physically and with skill development. The club is right to continue to push towards a more attacking and spread out game plan. I don’t know what the myth is? If people think we didn’t try last year to change that’s a myth. But it’s also fair to see that we regressed at various times through the year and probably played the old game plan about half the time. I do think it was mostly out of necessity and I hope we don’t have to do that this year.

Brisbane nearly won the flag in 2023 and finished top 4 for the best part of 5 or so years despite being poor in transition defending before it all came together enough late last year. Geelong 2022 were heavily reliant on Dangerfield winding back the clock to really be a strong midfield contest side. Brisbane have a heck of a list even if they just lost their most talented player. Sydney have a star studded midfield. Hawthorn are coming in a hurry. Freo are stacked. But otherwise the comp seems more open than it has been for a while so you don’t have to be near perfect. The concern is to reach attacking competence with the current list won’t be easy. And it will open us up defensive when our defensive systems have long been based on keeping the ball in tight and good structure.

There were 2 elements to the repeated turnovers that annoyed me. 1. Players not playing to the game plan they’ve been practicing. There was a lot of freewheeling rather than stick to the short kicks that they’ve been training. When they did manage to find a couple of short kicks it often opened up for the switch and there were a number of examples of a half back getting a handball receive, out to a wing, up to Chandler or another half forward and inside 50. 2. Bearing in mind I know they review trainings and I don’t know how in depth their reviews are, a lot of the stuff you see in drills translates to errors in match sim. Just one example but Kynan Brown in the point to point drill received the ball running to the right boundary and then took the time to not just straighten up but aggressively cut back on his left before hitting the target. First play of the game match sim - he gets the ball going right, takes a big cut back on to his left back in to traffic and is pressured in to a turnover.

The good news: we are full ground spreading and pulling the trigger. The bad news: right now there’s no rhyme or reason to the ball movement and the skill and decision making errors are ugly

Clarry’s handball gets deflected by Tracc. 20 seconds later Tracc’s handball gets picked by Clarry. Nice Bill goal Fritsch in the yellow link bib now. Goes to Mentha, kicks to no one, boundary throw in.

Verrall takes the kick from 30 out, misses Viney by a mile, Billings slams through the behind

Langdon hospital kick, cleaned up by Salo and AMW, out to Chandler, in to Salem, chain of handballs through the corridor for our first goal of the session

Rivers free running off half back, handballs to no one, turnovers are back

Pickett gets the short, switched to Salo, Windsor handball receive, Sharp wing, inside 50 kick touched by May for something a little better

Full ground grey v blue. Kynan Brown no right side, turnover. JVR bite off too ouch, turnover. T Mc kick out flat punt, turnover Harvey in the yellow

Forwards and backs in to a drill where 3 pairs run between a 1v1 at the goal square and 1v1 50 out crumbing, pressuring, scrapping. May keeps ruining the 1v1 50 out by winning ever contest, but there’s good scrapping otherwise. A big group of Mids - including, Pickett, Sharp, Windsor, Langford, Chandler with some contested handball work. Good pressure. Tommy Campbell and Verrall in that too. Big TC moves like the bloke from happy Gilmore but full credit to him he has a crack, Lindsay and Lever did rehab stuff.

Great energy in that drill and even more so on the sprint in to get a drink. XL’s field kicking is as advertised, he has penetration but also the sense of when to use touch. Sestan is such a lovely kick too, and Jeffo for that matter.

Full ground cone to cone drill now but the design is half back handball receiver in the corridor followed by a long diagonal switch to a fat side wing runner.

Roy George does look nice in the 23

Melk and Fullarton are doing short rehab drill movements. Soargo and Taj on long runs. Disco doing straight line sprints at a good clip, doesn’t look too restricted

From that photo, athletic profile and a private school background she sounds like an Eliza Mc clone. The way the Dees play requires elite running, worth a try to snag another one wherever you can find them.

Kind of sad we didn’t take Zippy Fish because it’s the best name of all time, but we wouldn’t be Melbourne if we didn’t draft the super athletic big bodied mid.

Yep poor from Shane. Should be out there doing laps with poo running down his legs leaving a trail behind him. Dont worry about the gps tracker, just follow the flow of brown to see how fast he’s going. Then make sure he touches as many water bottles as possible on his way back to Gosch’s. Thats commitment.

Chiefs, Commanders, Ravens

Top 8 all scored over 2000 points last year. 2100 seems like a reasonable target. 91 points per game, allowing for at least 7 points that’s 14 goals. Probably more like 13.5. There’s no chance we unearth a 70 goal kicker this year. That’s Coleman winning level. One of JVR or Disco probably get in position to kick 40 if they play the full year in a deep role. But I suspect we probably try a number of different combinations and structures during the season. Either of those guys could be the man for the FF role but we probably try both of them taking more time at CHF (as much as it exists these days), as well as Petty at times, as well as AJ and 2 or 3 talls and some Jeffo time too.

Still down back? I wish they’d give him a 3 game contract forward in Pickett’s absence

Waterman’s development was hampered by nasty injuries and a terrible eagles side. Meant he went from nowhere to star at 25. Disco has a chance to cement himself as a genuine afl player at 22, and a key forward at that. But I’d be shocked if he starts looking like a top 5 key forward in the comp like Waterman did overnight. I do think it’s pretty telling that they aren’t even experimenting whilst Lever is out with Disco swapping down back especially as Petty rolls forward at times. They’re giving Disco maximum reps to lock up a spot.

Jeffo with the smarts, long arms and clean hands AJ and JVR with power Disco with the combination of reading the drop and timing on the bump. If you could pick and choose the best parts you’d have 2 stars, just a matter of who plays to their strengths the most.

Last thing I want is Clarry playing hot potato with too many handballs, I want those burst runs back and when they come from stoppages they're a weapon. We can weaponise it in general play too as long as it's not going long and slow down the line to huge packs or waiting intercept defenders. Using the switches and the corridor is so vital because it means the mids then drive the ball to space inside 50. And space should mean one on one match ups. Our ball movement we've trained so far seems to focus on 2 tactics. 1. Fast counter, half backs taking off and using the mids to get through the corridor. And 2. short chips to play some tempo and tease out holes in zones. I'm intrigued how they blend those strategies together.

Having serious concerns that Pickett got stuck in the Monash carpark with the lack of Jefferson updates.