Jump to content

whatwhat say what

Life Member
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by whatwhat say what

  1. sparrow needs to be a lot more of a workhorse thru midfield to feature in our top 10 i'd wager nibbler i think is a chance, but i can't see sparrow getting a spot in our top 10 ahead of may, petracca, viney, lever, brayshaw, gawn, oliver, hunter, rivers, or pickett
  2. whatwhat say what replied to Romey's post in a topic in Melbourne Demons
    caulfield racecourse >>> fisherman's bend there's no way they'll make any announcement during spring carnival i wouldn't expect anything until at least may next year
  3. tell that to clayton oliver
  4. yeah but hawks did it all as free agents for the most part once they were in their 'win now' window, particularly by adding lake and frawley, while the tigs added lynch we had to trade for our equivalents thereof
  5. larkey, sheezel, ldu, simpkin, and thomas are an impressive top five players who knows what wardlaw will be, while bailey scott is getting better all the time, and phillips and powell look like good second tier mids, like sparrow, but you'd expect more from a pick 3 and 13 respectively add curtin as a key defender to develop plus another good ball user and they should get better quickly over the next few years
  6. i'd go further - make it 6 years and free agent for life i think the 'for life' bit actually does exist now, possibly?
  7. or, better yet, do away with compensation entirely?
  8. whatwhat say what replied to Demonland's post in a topic in Melbourne Demons
    2021 premiership, i assume
  9. why stop there? go to 13 to match the # on his back
  10. signed up at gc17 chol is the one on the market, and he's going to north - i suspect as part of the deal for their new magical future firsts for pick 4 etc.
  11. whatwhat say what replied to Demonland's post in a topic in Melbourne Demons
    to be honest, the king bros don't do a huge amount for me their primary ability is height, and they both suffer from a shortage of the greatest ability of them all; availability
  12. tagger - primarily roll is to stop the opposition player they're assigned to having effect on the play cooler - someone that you move on to someone when they're getting 'hot' to stop their influence on play reckon the phrase has been a thing for five or so years now?
  13. two nuffies talking rubbish they openly admit they have no idea what we're doing which, i suspect, is just the way that tim lamb likes it; we don't leak
  14. yep, another 'cooler'
  15. because the best teams don't deploy taggers - they use ball winners in terms of a 'cooler' we tend to send viney to stop the best stoppage player
  16. a wa ruckman with a name like that - superhero initials! - belongs at the dees
  17. i would say that it'll be band 1 otherwise they would've been given pick 3, immediately after their own pick, as an assistance pick
  18. he's played more afl games than his dad at the same age... i personally think his best role is an inside mid - he's the next cab off the rank given jj is out the door for that role
  19. i can't see us willingly let harmes walk along with jj we are light on for midfield depth as it is, let alone senior bodies inside mids in 2024: petracca viney brayshaw oliver sparrow woewodin even if you add rivers that's not a lot of depth
  20. whatwhat say what replied to adonski's post in a topic in Melbourne Demons
    gifted? no, allocated - as was the rule at the time how north got this 'assistance package' has been arbitrary and opaque big difference between this and us getting $cully plus i was more referring to the post-$cully era where neeld took us into the deep darks of mordor
  21. more likely given them these picks to enable them to get pick 4 but not direct access to riley sanders
  22. it all depends on whether those 2024 end-of-first-round picks are tradeable or not if they are, then north will jettison them quick smart because they wouldn't want to suddenly have 7-10 wins next year and lose em; better to use em this year they're in the box seat to get gc17's pick 4, which means in addition to their own pick and the likely compo pick for mckay they're likely to hold picks 2-4 inclusive at the pointy end of this draft it's the sort of compensation concession we would've killed for when we were a hot mess on field
  23. whatwhat say what replied to adonski's post in a topic in Melbourne Demons
    gives north the ammo to make a run at pick 4 and hold 2-4 inclusive geez we'd have killed for this sort of compensation-for-being-[censored] draft assistance when we were at our worst
  24. whatwhat say what replied to adonski's post in a topic in Melbourne Demons
    so if north trade out their two 'bonus' end of 2024 first round picks...how the blazes can they be reviewed if another club holds them?? helps having laura kane as the new head of footy eh, who worked at north first as a consultant and then as paid staff
  25. whatwhat say what replied to adonski's post in a topic in Melbourne Demons
    i'm expecting we'll go the key defender in o'sullivan if he's available with our pick, but i for one would love to add to our midfield stocks