-
Posts
45,278 -
Joined
-
Last visited
-
Days Won
72
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Events
Store
Posts posted by Sir Why You Little
-
-
15 minutes ago, Sydee said:
Like #4 for GWS ?
I can’t believe Greene was found innocent
Mac Andrews was slung to the ground and his head bounced off the turf….
WTF
- 5
-
On 08/04/2024 at 10:24, Young Blood said:
As much as I absolutely detest the man, I don't think Maynards action was premeditated before he left the air. He jumped to spoil/smother. Its once he was in the air he decided to turn his body and make full contact with his shoulder with the intention to hurt the player (Gus). I know its a lost cause but it still baffles me as to why old vision of the hundreds of times a similar situation occurred where the player in the air simply put their arms out to brace/push off the kicker was not enough to influence the decision. This is the duty of care we're talking about, not a thug taking advantage of a player in a vulnerable position.
Unfortunately while the impact is so different, the act is somewhat similar with Kozz. Leaves his feet to intercept/spoil the handball then decides in that split second to clip the players head with elbow. It was a split second but unnecessary. This part was not a football act.
Any other year he gets off. But not this year 😪
Maynard left the Ground after the ball had passed.
it was premeditated and executedFirst minute of the game
Lest We Forget
- 3
-
8 minutes ago, Demonland said:
Excellent. It deserves a challenge
- 2
- 1
- 1
-
I watched about 5 minutes of the Filth game. Can’t do it. My anger and disgust at them is too high.
it’s embedded into my entire bodyI just want to see them get hurt
- 7
-
11 minutes ago, Engorged Onion said:
I understand your desire to see Melbourne keep 'building' and attract top talent. It's definitely a key to success, like how Richmond rose to dominance through strong internal development. To be honest though.. I'm not sure explicitly what you mean by' keep building...'
You and I both know that winning the premiership every year is impossible and so is the feted dynasty once you've won one.
Melbourne's been a top 4 team for several years now, building a strong foundation. However, the AFL is cyclical. The draft and equalisation measures ensure a competitive balance, making sustained dominance very challenging. And players and coaches know that... (that' you'll be up for a max of 4 years and then drop)
With Geelong's (perhaps Sydney and Brisvegas) unique situation, their success isn't solely based on attracting top-tier talent from elsewhere. They've nurtured their own young players brilliantly, similar to what Richmond achieved. Melbourne has a talented young core too. Focusing on their development alongside strategic acquisitions, not just a rigid "build" mentality and keep winning is the path to longer sustained success or at least competitiveness (see Geelong).However, the AFL landscape is complex. While recruiting from within the top 4 is ideal, it's not always feasible. Salary caps, player loyalty, and a limited player pool, especially for Melbourne teams, make it tougher. Geelong's position is unique, their strong culture and geographic location can be very attractive to players, creating a situation most Melbourne teams can't replicate.
So, essentially, focusing solely on "building" can be restrictive. Sometimes, strategic acquisitions from outside the top tier can be the missing piece. Melbourne should prioritize getting the most value out of their draft picks and develop them. They seem to do that well... and like all clubs, some are hit and miss (and how much falls on the selection policy, vs the player or development structures remains to be seen)...
Ultimately, the right player will want to be at Melbourne, regardless of their current team's position. Building a strong culture and competitive environment attracts talent (that it exclusive to premierships)
pps... your demands on the recruitment staff... it's a bit old school don't you think??
I demand high standards from everyone within the Club.
We all know what failure was like.
There is no need to bottom out. Particularly with 2 new teams coming in.
Good Players have to be traded whilst the still have currencyYou cannot have all your stars retire at the same time
- 1
-
5 minutes ago, DeeZone said:
Agree SWYL it was nice to see him walking the full length of AO with Goody and Max on Thursday night and then in the rooms talking casually with the players, he’s doing a great job.
I didn’t see any coverage after the game. But i am glad to hear that
- 1
-
1 minute ago, DeeZone said:
Agree SWYL it was nice to see him walking the full length of AO with Goody and Max on Thursday night and then in the rooms talking casually with the players, he’s doing a great job.
He certainly knows what he is doing, Burgess set a very high standard, and Selwyn was there to see it.
It’s Roadtrips like this that prove to players why the hard work is so strenuous2 games in 5 days is an incredible amount of hard contact
- 5
- 1
-
7 minutes ago, Engorged Onion said:
I imagine we have already done our 'very best' - general exposure daily to our culture. If he still needs convincing, he is not the right person for the club - and that in of itself - is absoulutely fine when we as a club (or us as people) meet someone where they actually are 'at'.
I'm a lover of Ange - here is a recent link to a press conference - a few days old, about the need to make the Champions League (coming at least 4th, potentially 5th overall in the premier league) and how that allows a cash injection, as well as signals to potential athletes that Tottenham are now worthy of being recruited to.
I'd have the same approach to any athlete pondering coming or not coming (or staying) at the MFC...
Winning creates opportunities…
The MFC must keep building every year.
You can still recruit top line players from inside the Top 4, we need to pay our recruitment staff a high wage and expect high returns.
Look at how many 50 game players Jeelong bring in each year, ready to goTge MFC needs the same mindset
- 3
-
- Popular Post
- Popular Post
I think Selwyn deserves some credit after the Adelaide Sojourn
He was able to prepare the side for 2 games in 5 days in hostile conditions.
Burgess taught him wellWell Played Mr Griffiths
- 37
- 1
- 5
- 10
-
1 minute ago, 640MD said:
Stuff it I picked the saints
some of them like the pretty football not the grunt stuff,
They had their GF against the Filth.
Bathwater?
-
Toby Greene must be reported for his tackle on Andrews. slung him to the ground, head bounced on the turf.
-
2 minutes ago, ElDiablo14 said:
Tell Crypto.com to pay for it, since they love the advertisement during those ARC reviews. Btw, they should use spider cameras to have a bird's eye view of the action.
Spider Cameras can be one of many options available. There should be no hidden angle.
I want to see the AFL spend some money on the game, and not themselves for a change- 1
-
17 minutes ago, Dee Zephyr said:
Maybe the AFL can you use this fan’s phone for reviews. Pretty clear the ball deflects when you slow it down, maybe harder during real speed.
The AFL should all be sacked over this. But of course they will all survive.
They had 6 months to fully sort this out after the Adelaide debacle, and have done Sweet F$&@ all.
The Arc is pathetic. They spend time reviewing shots that are clearly fine, but refuse to make serious calls because the Cameras are total garbagewe the Fans and the Clubs must demand that the AFL fit 4k Cameras at every AFL VENUE
Paid for by the AFL, not the Broadcaster
Maybe the suits will have to take a Pay Cut
- 2
-
So the AFL have admitted that the Carlton goal was the WRONG decision.
GET SOME DECENT 4k Cameras fitted at every game ya Cheap Bastards.
All Clubs should go on strike until this is completely sorted out
It makes a mockery of the whole Competition
how I despise the useless overpaid suits who run the AFL
- 4
-
First time i have seen Jeeelong this year
I feel nauseous
They just will not die…
Hit Them Hard….😡
- 3
-
2 minutes ago, layzie said:
Carlton are once again becoming a team to hate
When did that ever stop?
- 4
- 1
- 3
-
It’s going to be very hard to beat Carlscum this year
What an absolute disgrace
that is Bordering on cheating, just like the Cripps Brownlow
- 6
-
6 hours ago, Stevienic23 said:
Absolute Gold
F off Essendon
i will never forget the years of my youth when you lot were arrogant and vile
watch your old VHS tapes and F off
- 7
- 2
-
Well this is the first time i have Seen Essendon for 2024
I still hate the Cu… just as much
and they are still useless….
- 4
-
7 minutes ago, Big Col said:
Nth have had plenty of drubbings too. Their percentage has been woeful for years.
If you look at the past 4 years, it's worse than any 4 year period we had during Bailey or Neild years.
Nth:
2023 - 3 wins
2022 - 2 wins
2021 -4 wins
2020 - 3 wins*(out of 17 games)
Melbourne's three year bad patch of 2012,2013 and 2014 (where signs of recovery were obvious) yielded 4, 2 and 4 wins. 2011 had 8 wins. 2015 had 7 wins. We won 5 games in 2008 and 2009.
They've had 4 very bad years in a row. If they have another bad year (as I stated in my post) without showing obvious signs of improvement they need help. I stand by that.
It’s too late now
Tassie will have first crack at all the Young Talent
North should have gone to The Gold Coast, but James Brayshaw said “no, i will save them..”
I have zero sympathy for this club
- 1
- 1
-
14 minutes ago, Axis of Bob said:
I didn’t say it can’t affect things, I said it is not important. This was especially so in a Melbourne context where it had no discernible effect on us last year. That was the whole point of the trend/noise discussion - umpiring variability can affect things in the very short term but, overall, it has such little impact that it’s barely worth thinking about. Certainly not the obsession that seems to be in this thread.
As for the metaphor, it is to help people understand what is being spoken about. The point had originally been made with noise and trend but this way was more inclusive for those who may not have understood the concept. As a recovering teacher, I usually prefer to help people access new concepts. If you already understood it then you didn’t need the help.
It’s also more fun.
Umpires certainly F$&@ Adelaide’s 2023 Season.
personally i think you underestimate their influence- 2
- 1
-
9 minutes ago, stinga said:
It was a good win, but I don't know why, when we get 5 or 6 goals in front we play defensively and try to save the game That was a great opportunity for a 10 goal win that we missed.
Be glad when Bowey comes back and can take Billings spot.
I think the whole team ran out of Gas last night.
it was a fantastic effort to defensively hold Adelaide to a loss- 8
-
16 minutes ago, Monbon said:
He was good in the first quarter as well. He busted his guts last night. My only criticism is he sometimes reverts to long bombs. We've been treated to how well he passes and, then again, many of his possessions are in the middle of scrimmages and guess who is always in the middle of them? I love the guy.
I think he long bombs so often because he is using so much strength to break free.
He was well tagged early, but was still a huge contributor- 3
-
6 hours ago, H_T said:
Oliver: not sure which one:-
• party time again
• couldn’t attempt spoil
• pulled up short
• very average game
• team carried him
• hand troubling him
He had a great last quarter
- 4
MEMBERSHIP TALLY
in Melbourne Demons
Posted
Any Membership Updates since the Adelaide Sojourn?