Sir Why You Little

Someone has to play the position Picket

It’s only Round 3, if he is given games for the next 2-3 weeks without showing progress i will agree with you

Ring the Club, i am just giving my opinion The Weid is obviously not up to it at this point (if ever) or Goodwin is a fool

That’s fair, but it was 2 years ago and he has done very little since at senior level. Missing that goal, to win the game up north last year didn’t help sadly

The Weid may well have been given a specific standard to reach you don’t know. I don’t mind Jackson getting a “taste” at all, IF he is still struggling in 2-3 weeks i will be asking questions. As it is we are still wondering about the Weid 5 years in There is a difference

He played well against Jeelong, i don’t recall the rest being of the same level, but the whole team lifted in that period so i will take your word for it.

Ask Goodwin why The Weid isn’t getting a game, i have given you my reasons, and that’s all they are. You just don’t like what i said Jackson is in, the Weid kicks with the morning dew

Clarry is tough, don’t get me wrong. Yes he does lay some hard tackles in the middle of the ground, but he needs to do more work around the ground to go to the next level He will get there...

1-2 games for Jackson now is not going to harm him either way. But the Weid is 5 years into his career and has still not cemented his position, and this is at the same time TMac is struggling. Tells me the Weid is not doing as well as he could, OR the club want him to do his thing over a sustained period before he plays Seniors When has the Weid played 2 good games in a row??

This is exactly what Clayton needs to lift towards. He is a gun Midfielder but he will be so much better if he can tackle more and kick 1-2 goals a game

Yep. Weid did well last week but he has to keep doing it, if he wants to be the number one target. The offer is waiting for him, because TMac is not a number one target up forward

Thankyou rjay Says more about a culture to me

Gotta pick 22 players each week The Weid was awful last year, he needs to kick bags of goals over a number of weeks, not just one performance. Jackson can play a couple of Senior games with Gawn and then step back if necessary Culture is on show tonight.

Jackson is getting a taste The Weid is getting up early 5 years. It’s time to find out what he is made of.

Cameron Ling working with Jab Watson is pretty bad. Add in Yobbo Brayshaw who sounds the same on MMM and the “other” McLachlan What a mess. Like an over filled Pizza ?

So the Weid is being made to earn his position in the team. Excellent. We will now find out if he really wants to get better

Whorethorn very rarely play 2 bad games in a row.... I hate them, but it is incredible how they just keep doing it

That would be highly entertaining to observe. Eddie and Kochie, 2 absolute ego driven wankers going toe to toe Port Adelaide look fabulous “behind bars” it’s their rightful place

Only when Teams like the MFC beat them with monotonous regularity It is ALL about winning....

Interesting take. Jake has talent, but we haven’t seen it yet, i have always been a fan of Performance Based Contracts There may well be a lot of love for JL in the room at the MFC, and that is all fine and good But the bottom line is we paid Top $$$ for a player to do a critical job. That’s the part i am interested in

I thought the Prison Bars looked excellent last Saturday, as long as they stay in South Australia. The Showdowns should be on Free to Air every year as do the WA derbys We miss out over here

We need good football out of Lever and May right now. They are on Top Shelf Coin, so far they have been underwhelming, injuries notwithstanding They have to fire up..

This is what he should have learnt under Roos, Anticipating what his opposition is going to do and having a counter plan ready. i haven’t seen this side of his coaching at all, and it is what concerns me. 4 years is a reasnoable time to see what someone can do. Anyone can fly a Plane these days when the systems are all functioning at the optimum performance. The great Pilots can land a Plane when the pressure is unpredictable and the Cockpit is in manual over ride. i didn’t see any innovation coming from the Melbourne Box after Halftime, so can Goodwin really coach? We will know fairly soon i think

The Murdoch Empire Utter Filth I will celebrate when Rupert croaks it

Agree with the above. But when Players are taking risks, we need other players to spread as back up Too often we see 2-3 sometimes 4 players going for the same contest, be it in the air or on the ground I don’t see why this should be happening when a coach has been in charge 3-4 years