jumbo returns

Tommy Mac is a lock

If Vanders was fit, no way he would have been dropped The team walks taller with this bloke in the team

I hope that Jonesy gets to his 300th and is then respectfully and honourably transitioned into our coaching team He deserves the best treatment possible Unwavering loyalty and professionalism One of the Melbourne FC greats

So........posters still want COliver dropped? Lol....

Not me, PF Very average footballer Nice bloke apparently... And, what's happened to the NBT, Petty??

Mebbe - but excitement and exuberance will shine through

Me too Realistic and practical point of view leads directly to no Brown

Brown a lock? Really??

No Brown Good move

I'll hold onto anything od He can gagf

I’m hearing you, too, Wise - Smith is tall and has a big leap on him He will be a handful for those three players you mentioned

He is His kicking has been limited to short passing as per the tempo of the game

No Thanks

Thanks for the debate Let’s agree to disagree Brown is a very poor footballer - Smith is quick, has a great pair of hands and can kick a mile

Brown will not win games

Smith has played a dozen games and has an upside Brown is not the way forward

But, he has no form and he's not up to AFL standard Smith has an upside

Yep - either Brown will not win you games of footy

There is always a reason why a player is delisted If Brown gets a game, we are going backwards Thus, I don’t agree with the recruiting Smith is a more exciting, developmental option

Good point Because he was there? Sometimes, this happens...why is KK on our list?

Paddy needs to focus on the longevity of his life that doesn’t include footy

No Brown If Tom doesn’t get up, Smith should play

What part gave it away?

I'm not giving Murdoch ONE RED CENT I want the bastard to go broke

I'm a fan - I reckon he's better than OMac