Flagdees

Would love for you to show me someone who gets it bang on after the first round, or even someone who gets the first round as correct as him

I know that a lot of people aren’t fans of co captain but I think rivers and disco co captains would be what I’d look into, both look to be future leaders, although with not many other options to go to they may have to head into it before they are necessarily ready which is why I’d like to see them do it together

Couldn’t agree more think they are very different players as Windsor dosent possess grjls agility and ability to evade opponents

Well I think physically they are very similar but from what I’ve seen cumming has more explosive speed out of the contest, has more impact when he’s forward and appears to be a smarter player

I’m not gonna lie to you I did miss that part, but I still believe through everything I’ve seen about this guy (idk if you’ve seen more of him live or stuff) it is way too harsh to judge his kicking like that, especially through what I’ve seen hasn’t been that bad

Well I personally looks for all the traits and attributes he does strongly throughout the video instead of picking out 2 mistakes that all the players in the draft crop make

honestly I think we should just take the best available player that manages to slide down to this pick, as long as there not clones to our first 2 picks, just think besides our lack of small forward crop I think we have enough depth in most parts of the ground to take best available

I’m a fan of farrow I feel like he is the short term rivers replacement developing in the back half while rivers goes into the midfield, with Farrow eventually going into the midfield when he’s ready

Grlj is actually a fairly tough competitor from all I’ve seen and willing to put body on the line

Sorry I’ve butchered the reply and don’t know how to fix it but anyway it wasn’t a knock on Schubert I was just talking about how when you play 4 tall forwards at Casey who are all young it can stunt there development and I hope your right but I’d still draft a mid rhis year as I still don’t think butters would entertain the thought of us

Yes roo and Jeffo probably haven’t been what we have hoped so far I wouldn’t give up just yet and Kentfield looks promising, adding Schubert hurts the develop of these guys and as much as I would love to get him unless we show off fast exciting football this season moving up the ladder we won’t land butters, we need to add to our young midfield brigade in this draft

I wouldn’t say there is a clear knock on him, but I don’t think he is what we should be going after with 3 developing young talls aswell as mihocek and Johnson I’d definitely look at a midfielder stil available (would love for it to be cumming) and dovaston

FB- Jiath Petty Turner HB- bowey lever lindsay C- langdon rivers culley HF- Viney JVR Fristch FF- Chandler Mihocek Langford FOLL- Gawn Windsor Pickett bench- Steele Kentfield Howes Salem Tholstrup Emergency- Adams Sharp Sparrow provided its one of robey or dovaston they would replace tholstrup in the best 23 langford rotating into the middle as a deep forward with pickett and rivers to play deep aswell

Would be a great get imo for the right price which is pick 42 imo, we need more medium/small defenders with Mcvee leaving and rivers going into the midfield, he can defend and has the speed that king has been wanting

going through roller coaster of emotions reading this thread

If we do lands picks 7 and 8 grjl and dovaston would be a great outcome

Well then your saying anb and trac are as good as each other? I’m just trying to point out that good young players are worth more then good older role players We are arguing about this but also agree that he’s worth an early second

Gotta look at the age difference tho mate Mcvee will still improve whereas ANB has reached his ceiling

That is a good point but I belive Mcvee would of been there aswell But I agree he’s not worth 12 but if we are adding the other picks to it I definitely think the package in total is worth pick 12

I’m asssuming they meant pick 26 and the spargo compensation which is likely to be end of second round Mcvee definitely has much more trade value then ANB as Mcvee is like 6 years younger then him and as good as him and I think he meant the pick that we get for may, not may himself

Would like to see him be moved into a pressure forward role, not sure he still has the ability to be a good midfielder

Yeah but then worrying about what players we want to trade for would be considered useless aswell but yes I said that before that it isn’t something we have to worry about currently because of the large space we have in our salary cap

Well I’m a Melbourne fan speaking in complete blind faith and hope here but hopefully the young boys start to develop and we start playing fast exciting football that attracts the big names like butters and king

Yes and I’m happy to overpay on certain players rn because we have the salary cap to do so I was just trying to point out how salary cap is something that shouldn’t just be brushed under the rug by fans

Because some supporters worry that there club might overpay players causing large struggles in the future loosing your best players because of tight money situations, I would like for us to get better whilst being reasonable in the amount of money we give players