Half forward flank

It is a good what if. If we had King last year, we could have had Green this year. Also would have kept Frost who is the equal of Lever.

One can only assume you are a fairly new supporter to the Dees or another of the plants that feature here to defend the decisions of the Club

Make a call.

Never thoughtI would feel the same. Be quite happy to follow the jumper if they had /go to the Gold Coast. Attend a few games over winter and be rid of the old school tie, big end of town, brigade thinking.

You didnt address the question of your relationship to the Club. We could have taken Green

Come clear, tell us your relationship with the Club We should have taken Green instead of Jackson who is still a few years away. Langdon can run but that is what wingman are meant to do, oh yeah and hit a target. Tomlinson, already exposed for the average AFL player he is.

Second-gamer Tom Green was close to the match-winner for the Giants against the Magpies with his assured presence at the death. The 19-year-old is a bullocking midfielder more synonymous with yesteryear who possesses the rare double of sparkling clean hands and calmness in the heat of a heavy pack. He finished the game with 13 handballs for 18 total possessions, 12 of which were contested and an equal game high seven clearances. Some of his clutch hard-ball wins late in the game, where he stylishly lifted the ball above his head, allowed his side to hold onto their narrow lead. He will be a joy to watch for years to come. Tom Green. The player we should have taken in the draft. Jackson may become a stsr but he is two years behind this bloke and always a chance to go home.

Sorry but that is rubbish. All teams were set to play the ful 120 minutes-what you call endurance. Now all teams have to make an adjjustment of 4 minutes per game. We have as young a side as anyone and if we are not quick whos fault is that?

Scenario that is not going to happen. Goodwin is unavailable to coach this week. A new coach picks his side with a different vision and altered plan NOW who thinks we can win?

I think he has been coached poorly throughout his career. He has enormous courage and fight, no need to encourage that aspect. I think coaches should have worked more on his craft. He is rover size and that is how he should play more. Get the easy tap from Max, be creative, get in position to kick the odd goal resting in the pocket. He is somewhere between a good first and second rover.

2018 Brayshaws best, Viney 10 games.

Mate, I grew up supporting the Dees in the Southern stand, to be precise, right in the middle, top deck, where the Cheer Squad used to sit throughout the late sixties and seventies. For fifty five years I have been correct in saying we dont have the players or the structure to win a flag. Nothing is different this year, in fact we are further away than ever. I have never been one of your chaps and will continue to have emotional involvement, you do what yuou like.

In: Brown, Bennell Out: Salem VDB Viney to back pocket. Brayshaw more game time. Kozzie some mid time. Shake it up time.

I know nothing of club dynamics but the one between Viney and Brayshaw does not work. I think Viney gets the majjority of game time and gets to contests other could. Brayshaw is in his shadow.

I need to see the replay but pretty sure it was when Salem had the ball at the death. No one mad a good lead for him. No one did a dummy lead. No one co ordinated with any other forward. It looks like we practice for close finishes at stoppages but not in a set play from a mark.

Which is exactly your personality type. Instead of criticizing performance of player, coach or club you specialice in criticising those who have an opinion.

Came in from the side, memory of the great Greg Parkes. That said I would give TMac one more game in hope.

Nice cop out. See us push up the ladder quickly, Might just not be this year.

No one has ever doubted his guts and determiination. Team players create opportunities for others and link play. Vivey does neither very well and has had a golden run of valuable on ball time at the expense of others all the while roving under the best tap ruckman in the league. He should be considered for trade on the same terms as all the other players if this season goes that way it might.

Tmac marked once.

Call it early, call it midway or call it late. There are problems with this Coach and playing group.

Tmac presented and marked once. Other Clubs also few games in 10 months Like anti Neeld? I argued with one of your mob the Suns have gone past us as a Club Lever, has not proved anything yet.

Mids remind me of kids at cricket who put their best scores on their bat. Love to rake up meaningless possessions. Unable to find a man with their kicks. No wonder Hogan used to shake his head. We need a commanding forward who will give it to our over rated mids if they dont lower their eyes or time thie kicks.

Gawn some support please Viney time to trade Oliver take game on Petracca never got going Tomlinson not a wingman Brayshaw plays as chore. Langdon seen nothing yet. Salem never impressed me Harmes tough game today Hibberd did well today Melksham is not Bosustow Hannan Victorian Football League Rivers learning the trade May earned his keep Smith earned his keep Lever some crutial errors Hunt not good enough VDB Game gone past Pickett play first rover/forward Goodwin lost in space.

I am glad you saw it too. it was a pivotal moment and really a set play. Streaming out of the centre and kick to advantage. Viney is a/the prime cause of our delivery as he is given a green light in the midfield. A position every small mid in the AFl would give their right arm for with Gawn tapping down. Kozzi is a natural born rover.