Half forward flank

Do not tell me how to comment. If you cannot see the difference to appointing someone to your board as opposed to bringing them into the coaching or playing ranks that is not my problem. If you think Brown and Smith is what we need most. Well, good luck to you. As it happens I have rarely agreed with our recruiting choices for 56 years. This is a weak, losing Club in every respect. I love the jumper and the odd player but little else about it now. We are a joke with our we can beat anyone on our day mantra. Can you imagine what Clubs like Richmondsay about us behind closed doors. Sweat on them, put pressure and they will fold. And time and again they are proven correct. Go back and have another look at that game and objectively ask yourself if a 32 year old Smith and a 28 year old Brown with a poor finals record of eight disposals is what we need most.

And the Tigers pay the players the same $$$ in salary cap as us, and yet some here defend our recruiters and list managers. It is time full a full and uncomprimising review of how we value players.

Wasnt Brad Green at another Club 5 minutes ago.

Smells like we need him because we are not as progressed in finding somewhere as Pert said.

Coach and Club to look at the GF, acknowlege we are a long long way of in so many areas.

I could have detailed more but refereing to Brown CHF as being our greatest need as in recruiting. Finals record 7 games, 9 goals, average of 8 disposals.

Sure there is an exception or two, but they like each other.

How mature are the Tigers compared to our guys.

I saw the Smith one. And who could forget Bruns. Today those charges may have stuck, and that would have been the end of him

Tragic. We are now at the stage where we think we did well by not taking the best player.

That sanp was a shocker

I didnt not even look at his highlights. Are you suggesting highlights cover all his games. Gees I am over people here who want to argue the toss all the time.

Rather pick another Rivers. We are not in the short term window. Still 3-4 years away.

Mathews would be rubbed out of the game nowdays.

What struck me was the certainty hardwick had at half time that he had fixed the set up problems of the first half. Amazing. We are a mile off. Hope Yze and others can make a difference to our planning on the run.

After watching that just not buying CHF as our greatest area of need.

Taylor is finished.

Rabbit in the headlights tonight.

Anyone think to ask grimes if his brother was any good.

Thought the same.

Insulting to say to someone who has experienced nearly 60 years of ineptitude and failure.

Must diagree. Carry the name of the city means nothing when the suburban names are themselves Clubs. Others play at the G, no advantage. Financially secure until we spend and maintain a home base. We are nowhere near Top 4. The rise to be Richmond like starts with an honnest assessment. 2021 Our best player and coach will likely be gone if we dont go deep into finals.

So true, and to applies somewhat to a Club establishing at Casey with its large growing population and the Gippsland towns and coastal areas for Country liking players and families.

Defend all you like but the fact is we basically pay the same salary cap as everyone else and continually miss the finals and never achieve success. So the FGeelongs, Richmonds and all the others who have tasted success are better list managers than us. Thats all there is too it. Results. Not interested in your, but he came third in the brownlow type arguments.

Yeah you are missing something. Turned my back on you so go jump.