Roost it far

He’s going to need to work very hard to play a senior game. He does have that TDK look going for him so who knows.

Was the reply "Win a Flag at OUR home ground" ?

Who says we’re not a destination club!

After all this we’ll likely lose Jordan, Harmes, Grundy, swap a few draft picks and go to the draft. Feels like we’ve missed Reid and surely McKay’s not going anywhere. Curnow for all his excellence was a complete bust when it really mattered. Carlton won’t ship McKay off unless it’s a godfather deal and we ain’t giving them that……or are we?

To help us win Flags, at least the next 2.

I'd take him for a pick in the late 20's. It's a pity they don't want Grundy. Straight swap oughta cover it.

If he runs out in a Melbourne jumper I will Boo him.

I just want this spud off our list. He gave us very little and he still smells like a Collingwood player. I’ll boo him at my pleasure next year 😂

How’d you know?

That’s Gold right there

I would of happily replaced Oliver with Petty in the finals

The Tiges won 3 flags with a weaker list but they never ever rolled over

If we had real strength we would have beaten Carlton by 6 goals, rolled Brisbane and smacked the Pies. We watched Gawn go down against Brisbane in round 2 and ran to Mummy. Then watched Gus go down and ran crying to Mummy. Then lost our innards and got rolled by Carlton. Teams with deep fortitude and resilience just don’t do that. We’re a bit weak.

Once again we’re at a point where we are being tested as a club. Again I think we lack the internal fortitude to come out stronger. Hopefully I’m wrong but……..

Massive unders, were basically giving up Pick 5 and Oliver for Reid and a later pick.....

It’s pretty clear the club are prepared to move mountains to get Reid. They’ve long wanted him. I’d suggest the club has allowed the Oliver story out to see what comes back. The chance of it happening remain very small. I’m backing the club on this.

I saw him interviewed on On The Couch. He’s a bogan who’s been forced into finishing school. It was cringeworthy viewing.

Personally I think it’s all [censored] and Nudge claiming to have been in the know smells like that [censored] but hey, I’m upfront that I know nothing.

He’d be a great get I think.

You’re not a trade breaker

If North think they’re getting Reid and an Oliver deal is in the offing then Sheezel could be part of the deal. I still can’t see it happening.

Personally I’d prefer to upgrade our running players than sell the farm for a key forward like McKay. I also think we should be drafting the next May. Don’t get me wrong if we can get McKay for 2 first round picks outside the top 10 I’m ok with that. But pick 5, give me someone more dynamic and game breaking.

Lobb is a spud, hard no lynch would work mcKay if the price is right, the mill a year is fine it’s the draft picks they’ll ask for

The problem can be seen that way. If you watch us though we regularly burn teammates forward of the ball. This is the bigger problem. Clubs know if they pressure the ball carrier we’ll make mistakes

Players need to be open to redoing contracts. He would still be a Pie for $650K, A million is overs