Mel Bourne

Have to agree with this. Yes, there will always be a contingency who wear their bigotry with a bewildering pride, but there is an enormous chunk of the troll-market who would immediately vanish if faced with actual accountability. The only time I could see an avatar as worthwhile would be for forums where people need to discuss highly personal problems (such as whether or not to play Harmes in defence).

Maybe he is being himself?

Cue the scene in The Club with Geoff Hayward staring at the seagull, mid-game.

Oh no, never would suggest the loss was on him. But the focus of attention was well and truly (and unfairly) on him at the end of that game. The camera glued on him in the rooms (when he was visibly upset) while commentators picked over the moment, was pretty rough on him. And if you want to put moments and games like that behind you, you have to bury them with dominant, undeniably good performances. He has yet to have that game since. I hope he does. It would do him and us the world of good.

Ah, gotcha. Thanks.

Is it significant beyond the fact his cousin used to play for the Saints? Not being rude. Genuinely curious.

I too wouldn’t mind seeing that, but not so keen on swapping for TMac. I just don’t think he’s got the necessary foot-speed to keep up with young gun forwards all day.

I think that missed goal against the Crows in Darwin last year really rattled him. The media made a stupidly big deal of it - cameras capturing his emotional state in the rooms, opinion pieces by journalists saying the club showed him too much empathy. It was a bit much considering his was just one mistake of plenty at the hands of his teammates through the night. But I can’t recall a game since where his performance well and truly left that night in the dust. Possibly nothing in that observation. But it’s also possible that it’s another example of our inadequacies when it comes to managing the psychological aspects of the game.

Yes, he has the *potential* to be a star. Why would you suggest otherwise? For somebody who made their debut last year (and came through the ranks quickly), he showed a lot of class and composure in some big moments. I’m excited to see what he can offer the club with his first full pre-season behind him.

Agreed, they aren’t. But he’s not going to become that star by watching from the sidelines.

Lockhart is far from a fringe player. He has the potential to be a star player. Jones is taking up his spot in the team these days.

Some fairly intense Demonlanding going on here.

With all due respect, the claim that players are coming to play for Melbourne because of Goodwin needs to be substantiated. I have never heard that reason mentioned by any player in public before, and I’m struggling to think of why any player would actively seek to be coached by somebody without any major (coaching) achievements to their name, and who’s team is not exactly setting the league on fire. I’m not saying that he’s necessarily repelling players, but attracting them? Nah.

Yes, I watched that genuinely hoping that I’d see a side of SG that was at odds with the public persona. It wasn’t really there, was it.

It would have to weighed up between the cost of paying out Goodwin vs the cost of a mass exodus of members. If we have two non appearances in finals 20/21 I honestly don't know if I'd bother anymore. Tough thing to admit to after close to fifty years of being a supporter. In the final few minutes of last night's game I had a brutal reckoning.... I really do love the club, but we have consistently been the worst Australian Rules team I've witnessed in my time on earth, and that [censored] gets genuinely tiresome.

What is this “progress” you speak of?

Yze. Has been studying under Clarkson for eight years now. It's time to bring him home.

Simon Goodwin out. Adem Yze in. Make it happen, dark overlords of thine miserable pit.

Look he’s rubbish but at least he’s expensive.

We should replace all of our players with those guys from the first quarter.

If you regard chickening out of a question with childish, cliched insults “winning”, then yeah I guess I “lost”. Anyway, you’re about to become the first person I’ve ever put on ignore here, and ignorance will indeed be bliss.

Dude. Enough. You’re embarrassing yourself.

Always best to avoid the twittery #MAGA jargon, if possible.

The poster is literally saying “defund the ABC” and you’re telling me that nobody here is saying they don’t do anything well.

You’re suggesting Sky News is an impartial news source. The same Sky News Which employs Andrew Bolt and Chris Kenny to voice their “impartial” views to the country on a regular basis. That Sky News? FMD.