Gawn's Beard

The key forward is hard to trade for. Normally have to give up a warchest. FA appears the better way to get them to the club so perhaps that can be the strategy next year? B+ for me but will move north or south once the pick 3 debacle has been resolved

If GWS don’t come to the table, they effectively “lose” their high 1st round pick on Green (which they could use later picks on). Do a deal with us then they use pick 3 on the player they want and later picks on Green, effectively 2 top 5 picks for pick 3, later picks and whatever they pay us.

Trade period isn’t over yet - I would be surprised if we had pick 3 come time of selection

Nobody heard about our pick swap yesterday until it happened so I’m hoping it’s just us running a tight ship...

The deal with North yesterday didn’t need to happen this window so would suggest we have plans for it

Perhaps it’s happening and @Yokozunais staying silent until it’s announced!

Just out of interest, what was the last positive thing you think Melbourne did?

We have a stronger position now with GWS. Bidding at 3 now bumps our pick 8 to 7. Really just further increases the value of 3 to them and the price for trading out pick 3.

Do GWS have any choice but to give up a player? They still need enough points to pay for Green so paying us 2 first rounders would appear to leave them short.

We have later picks than that. If needed it goes up into the 100s doesn’t it? Alternatively, you have one less on the list and pick up a DFA

If it involved our pick 3 I could see McKay and Ratugolea potentially being available (Cats and Blues have both been asking about pick 3).

I’ll narrow down to who I’d be excited about (and those which are unrealistic ie Daniher, Lynch and Reiwoldt) from the previous list: Josh 'Basil' Bruce Jack 'Basil' Gunstan Harry 'Basil' McKay Josh 'Basil' Schache Charlie 'Basil' Curnow Ethan 'Basil' Tremblay' Ben 'Basil' Brown Tim 'Basil' Membrey Esava 'Basil' Ratugolea

Happy with that - not sure how much benefit we derive from a JJ or Hawkins who won’t be around for more than 2 seasons. Thanks for the update Yoko - appreciate it!

Good stuff Yoko. Without saying a name, you heard whether it’s progressed at all?

So effectively a future second rounder. Backing ourselves to have a much better year. With next years draft having many F/S and Academy picks, this is an excellent result

Let’s see how creative we can get: - Pick 3 to GWS for Pick 6 and Caldwell - Pick 6 to Geelong for Pick 14 and Ratugolea (Just jumping on the ridiculous trade bandwagon)

Papley wants a massive salary and would cost a warchest of picks. Tomlinson came with at no cost (picks) and on a reasonable contract... How about we wait until the end of the trade / draft period before we lose our marbles?

Darcy Fogarty (he’s not at a Vic club so it’s not him) or Ratugolea would be the two i’d be keen to target and would suit our list profile.

Would solely turn on what Freo would accept for Langdon.

Sam Mitchell made a pretty good career out of being slow, small but having an excellent football brain. Not saying Spargo is comparable to Mitchell but you don’t have to be quick, tall and kick 60m to be a superstar.

Offer what? Adelaide might be asking for a 2nd rounder for all we know

Pick 4 and steak knives for pick 3?

Esava Ratugolea?

No model is going to fix a basketcase ownership / management structure (ie Knicks)... Are we the modern day Knicks of the AFL?

It’s heading that way. They are slowly adopting the American (NBA) model, which I think is sensible. Players have too much power at the moment. I think that we’ll ultimately get to: - FA & trade from Monday following Grand Final to prior to first game / bye weekend - Trading of future picks at any time during the trade period - Tradinng of players permitted immediately after you’ve drafted them - Lottery for the top 10 selections in the draft I would also like to see a “waiver” system where you can delist players at any time (you’d have to pay out their contracts) and pick up a free agent (ie someone who has been eligible and nominated for a draft and has been overlooked / delisted). Seems to work in the NBA where few teams are up / down for prolonged (ie MFC) periods of times.