ProperDee

Nah but vaporub to a groin injury will improve his speed.

I don't mind some of your posts but to say that about Hogan is a non-supporter comment. He's regularly double teamed and been carrying a niggling injury for over a month. He played last Saturday still feeling the effects of illness. What's your excuse for being a [censored]?

Fluke. Is a liability most games.

The poor bugger is double teamed when in the forward line however when opposition teams go forward their forwards are one on one! Goody needs to clear our forward line right out. One on ones against Hoges, TMac and Jeffy and/or Tracs and Clarry occasionally would be a nightmare for any defence. We just have to maximise the skills that those guys have. The problem is, we don't. Most of the time our forward 50 looks like an under 10's game.

Agree totally. ma ma hu hu b! Ni mingbai putonghua wo de pengyou? Don’t say “ma ma hu hu”.

As goodoil said!

DH.

That sounds better than the ACL injury I heard!

Just heard that Billy Stretch may have injured a knee. Hope that mail is completely wrong.

He is very well named....WaynCar.

The bloke Lewis hit is a noted diver/stager. It looked like Lewis hit his upper shoulder but he clutched at his face. This staging BS is becoming more prevalent in our game. Mathieson & Christensen from the Lions, Joel Selwood, Lindsay Thomas and Rance come readily to mind.

Good to see. A measured response. Honestly, 37 scoring shots and winning a game in horrendous conditions by 9 goals and some of you are calling for multiple changes? Go and headbutt the nearest wall and think again. Sheeeet, it’s hard to please some people.

6. Oliver 5. Salem 4. Gawn 3. Brayshaw 2. Petracca 1. Frost

Mens rea.

Fat Eddie making a note re the Collingwood fan comment as I write no doubt.

Yep. That’s their primary role.

....with petrol.

Good player in a great team. Not a “champion” for mine. Better players? Hmmm....KB, Daicos, even Jeff Farmer perhaps?

Maybe SF. His cameos probably totalled 7 or 8 minutes compared to the usual 5. Apologies for the sarcasm but he has really gotten under my skin. He should be killing it but my wife’s 14 year old dachshund has more desperation for a tennis ball than Petracca has for a footy.

Mate, you are a legend. You remember the first three performances of a then unknown Carlton kid from 15 years ago and that he showed “heart”? Gimme a break FCS.

FMD. Bet Carlton are happy they didn't flick Kade Simpson after his first 3 games which were all zero possessions.

Really? You can see that in a teenager playing his first game? Mate, you must be a genius. Or something else.....

It’s all been said but I have to vent to release some of this anger. Playing Jack Viney as a tagger is one of the worst coaching decisions I have ever seen. Tyson should never play for the MFC again. I wish Harmes would just play team first football instead of trying to do the heroic/spectacular every time he goes near the footy. ANB? Not a footballers ahole. Never has been. Never will be. I feel sorry for Harry Petty. Thrown in on spec. Not his fault. Will come good I’m sure. Frost has clearly murdered Goody’s cat. I harbour serious doubts about “The Weed’s” progression to senior football. Our coach (and Petracca) needs to start getting angry.

Regardless of his form, I can't help thinking that with all of those inside 50's last week Jeffy would have gotten on the end of at least a few of them.

Great article. It highlights issues that on face value, our coaches can easily remedy one would think. It also highlights the glaring lack of a Plan "B" which has been the cause of my elevated blood pressure on a number of occasions this year.