Dr.D

he's right on most of his points to be fair.

McDonald for Brown. Problem solved

Viney - doing too much. Petracca - lacked usual impact Brayshaw - No real impact. Oliver - One good goal. Fritsch - kicking woes continue. Hibberd- was well beaten Lever - Makes poor decisions. May - Ultimate Oscar upgrade. McDonald - Moves like grandpa. Weideman - Kicked his 2 Langdon - Found usual space Tomlinson - barely noticed him Melksham - costly brain-fades vandenBerg - More costly frees Pickett - slow fu$%#ng down! Lockhart - Not out worst Harmes - In wrong position Hannan - lost his way Spargo - Looks slow again Preuss - Had a crack Salem: Just a game.

when's that? If I was playing tag with Mcdonald he'd never lay a hand on me. He's super slow and has no lateral movement. I'd delist both McDonald's and show them the door.

Goodwin and Tom McDonald.

I can envision Goodwin sitting with Richardson in the box an hour after the game like Dumb and Dumber be like 'ahhhhhh yeah, we probably should've got Harmes to tag bontempelli'. The guy is thick as bricks

Blind Freddy could see that Harmes needed to tag Bontempelli today.

Bloody Goodwin shown up yet again. He has no plan B. Surely at half time when our midfieldwas was vetting smashed that you would change things up. And that's why you don't play Tom McDonald. I think I am literally a better player than Tom McDonald. Not even joking. Please sack Goodwin and be done with it!

What the [censored] is going on without our [censored] structure after a behind?? Why are we conceding the kick to the pocket??? Why are we [censored] conceding the next kick to the d50, then the wing, then the forward line. That's structure. Goodwin can go and get [censored] you stupid robotic sociopath.

what sort of coach is Goodwin! look at how laughable our defensive structure is after a behind! go f#$% off Goodwin.

Goodwin is so crap. send someone to bontempelli ffs. we clearly haven't addressed any of the defensive accountability stuff.

a) it will shut down one of their stars and b) show a sense of accountability which wasn't on show by any melbourne midfielder

Viney tries to do wayyyy too much. Get the bloody ball going you goose. and brayshaw drop giving frees away

Good job goodwin. Letting Macrae, Hunter, Bontempelli and Smith get as much of the footy as they please. Stick a tagger on one of them as set a defensive mindset you hack of a coach.

Yeah, he wanted to go home. he wouldve become one of the dees all time greats. I knew it. I don't think the dees were aggressive enough.

As long as he have Oscar and Tom McDonald on the list, how could anyone say that they wouldn't have Hogan back? I'd take him back immediately

I wouldn't exactly listen to the fans. Half you demonlanders wanted Oliver dropped. game set and match

i'm sorry but theres nothing used up about Higgins. Pickett has already been extremely fumbly and lacked composure, literally the exact opposite of Higgins

source?

Current: Oliver Past: Scott Thompson (that trade STUNG!)

umm yes. That's clearly his value. All industry experts would agree.

Are you serious? Papley is worth 2 first rounders. Why would Sydney want Tom McDonald who has been in and out of a side and overtaken by a 18 year old ruckman? To be serious, it'd be our 2nd rounder, next years first and Tom McDonald for Papley. You are why trades get done. That trade would get laughed out the door at

i really don't rate Goldstein. And also, it's incredibly media driven the hype around him. If anyone actually tracked him, he's been very down on form 5 of the last 6 weeks where it looked like Daw had won starting ruck off him. Also, a hell no to Cripps. One of the most overhyped players because he is the prototype 195 midfielder but he was had a down season and gone missing in games for hours at as time. Swap him with Menegola.

my track record speaks for itself. Were you one of the many demonlanders that wanted to drop Oliver? lol. right

since when did Tomlinson become a defender? not sure why his name is even being mentioned to be honest.