The Panglossian

The players make it well known who they think are the best umps. I have heard it said that the players all think Stevic and Rosebury are the best umpires. I'm sure this influences the AFL Umpire selectors in their choice for the Finals. It probably should. Stevic seems like one of the best to me, but I feel strongly he let down all umpires by not being more critical of Toby's act. There's no doubt junior footballers copy what they see on TV of footy at the highest level. Stevic's done nothing to make umpires in lower grades safe.

I reckon Stevic deserves a reprimand for his virtual "sticking up' for Greene in his post-incident interviews. By not "lagging" on players, the umpires know they'll be highly rated by them, increasing their chances of Finals selection etc. But Stevic let down his umpiring colleagues at all levels by not renouncing Greene's behaviour . He shouldn't have been selected for Finals this year.

I think the scar visible on Gary Lyon's chin is a result of a behind-the-play elbow from that animal, Ablett. Lyon was holding Ablett almost kickless that day on the MCG, till Ablett did a "Matthews", and knocked him out when the ball was 100 metres away.

I feel so sorry for him when watching the immediate post-siren rush of players on to the ground. He was as rapt as anyone..Then to be delisted the next day.....I hope they'd given him some prior notice, perhaps suggesting he try again after getting some experience elsewhere. It was also noticeable that Nev Jetta had tears in his eyes as he came on the field...he so much deserved to have been there.

Where's your analysis?

............."He maketh Dogs lie down in green pastures"

I'll never forget our '64 GF win. I was 14,so could use one of my Grandfather's MCC Ladies tickets. We got to the MCG about 10 o'clock, but the best seats we could find were on the top level of the Olympic stand. We assumed we'd kill Collingwood, having slaughtered them by 89 points in the 2nd Semi. We were pretty worried at half time(down by a point, I think), and memories of the '58 disaster(I was also at that), were flooding back. Our hearts sank when Gabbo kicked that goal. We didn't know how long there was to go. Hassa Mann, normally a reliable drop punt kick, missed a sitter from dead in front. We were ecstatic when Froggie put us in front, but there seemed an eternity after that before the siren rang. Coll. had the ball in their forward line a couple more times, but didn't score. I'll never forget the triumphant feeling as we filed out of the ground. It took ages to get over the railway bridge to Swan St, where we'd parked, but we didn't care because we were surrounded by happy Demon supporters. I want to feel that way again tonight!

NO...it was Donlon,Williamson and Fleer....who all should be ashamed of themselves after that debacle.

This excellently researched post worries me a lot. Especially in view of HB's next post, where he mentions that Stevic was involved in the reprehensible pro-Dogs umpiring in the 2016 Grand Final between Dogs and Swans. I also referred to this in my (much ignored) post on.."how do the Bulldogs do it?" I know it's no use worrying about the umpires, but these facts revealed by "Hells Bells" should be made as public as possible to make sure such gross inequity is not repeated in the Grand Final. The argument that you get the frees if you're in first for the ball is fallacious. There was little difference in total disposals in 2016 GF, but a huge difference in frees .Ditto in round 19 between us and Dogs. I just can't help worrying that the trend of the Bulldogs getting an armchair ride will be continued on Saturday night, and the better side will lose, as in round 19.

In the knowledge that the Dogs usually get an armchair ride from the umps, I'm a bit worried about the appointment of Stevic for the Grand Final. He umpired the 2016 Grand Final, where the umpiring was so one-sided for the Dogs, that the Swans submitted an official complaint in the week after the match. I think Stevic should have been reprimanded for his attitude and statements after the Toby Greene bump. He let down his peers, and all umps, in all levels of football by virtually sticking up for Greene. Of course that's how you become popular with the players, to not "lag" on them. If it's known the players like you( as we know they do with Rosebury), it increases your chance of being selected for finals.

I wonder how GWS would have gone against Port.. I think I'd rather be playing them, now.

I noticed even the US Open tennis ladies champion wore Demon gear. It's catching on!

Hey Jack....can we watch the first Semi on some sort of streaming?

We finished above the Dogs, so we should get choice of umps!

It hasn't!!! But I hope we get the same umps in the GF that we had last Friday! They were hardly noticeable... but I always feel embarrassed on the rare occasions we get more frees than the opposition!

Isn't it in Simpson St, near Albert St? I haven't noticed it in Lansdowne St.

Please can we have the same umps we had on Friday!

Does anyone know how you can tell what priority one, two, three ...etc means? Does it depend on how long you've been a member? I'm a platinum member(41 years). Am I in tier 1, or is that the same as priority 1? Does ticketmaster have access to the MFC's list of members and their eligibility for GF tickets? (I'm hoping to get a ticket for my nephew in Perth) (Freo supporter but will be flat out for the Dees)

This thread will really fire up if it's a Dees/Dogs Grand Final!!!

Hey, Titan ,I don't know how you can be so absolutely definite the Duryea soccer kick wasn't deliberate. I reckon the TV footage shows it was undeniably "deliberate" , under the current interpretation of the law. Did he make an attempt to keep the ball in play? No....his soccer kick had the best possible result ...out of bounds. Did he intend to kick it out?(knowing that would be a great result) It wouldn't matter, if a Dee had done it....deliberate!!! Somehow the "Scraggers" have the umps in their pocket. Their ability to be on the right side of 50:50s has won them another Final.( as in the 2016GF).

I think it wasn't paid because the ump was behind Cameron and Duryea, and couldn't see which boot hit the ball. I can't help but think , if the Dees were in that situation, the Ump would have run in triumphantly signalling deliberate. But I'm hopelessly one-eyed. ( and will remain so).

I think the most significant decision in the game was the decision NOT to penalise Duyrea(spelling?) for deliberate when he and Cameron chased the ball in the last few seconds. Would have been a shot for goal from about 45m out.....probably a crucial point. So the pure free kick count doesn't reflect completely the good fortune a club receives from the umpires. Also, another point of inconsistency of the umps is when they call play-on after a free or mark. Sometimes they call "play on" when the player takes half a step off the line, then decides not to play on. Other times they don't call it. Other possible benefits of umpiring decisions not reflected in the free count are.... how long they give a player before yelling play on, 10metre kicks marked and paid, throws not called, etc. The Dogs do well in all these adjudications, and have done so for decades.

I think Stevic's testimony was reprehensible. As I suspected, he tried to ingratiate himself with the players by not incriminating a star. In doing this , he's let down his fellow AFL umpires, and all umpires at all levels of Australian football. It's noticeable that ex-player media( like Jonathon Brown), and players like Treloar and Petracca , are also reluctant to be too critical of Greene. A bit more understandable from them, since they're in the "Boys' Club". But Stevic's performance was unforgivable.

i just watched the replay of our loss to GWS earlier this year. They worry me, even without about 4 of their best players. I think they'll kill the poor , old, slow, Cats. Most Demonlanders obviously think differently..