Members' Wing

Good lord.

Drums are beating because a journalist with zero credibility writes that in his opinion they should be traded?

"The Hogan trade"?

That is insane. Anyone with even half a brain would take Blicavs last of those three.

Or Whitfield.

Dean Kent.

Gaff is both of those things. We've got enough inside ball winners - you won't win a flag if you've got too many of the same type. He's exactly what we need.

Why?

What an odd post. Let's just get the best people for the job in all positions at the club, on and off field. Doesn't matter one iota whether they come from 'within' or not. Not a single member of our senior coaching staff has come from 'within'. Why would this make any success we have "an illusion"?

Huh? Not sure you understand the trade system. 90% of trades happen when players are out of contract. Much harder to trade players under contract.

Very limited player. Wouldn't get in the side before Pedersen or Weideman. Would hardly have made the difference between finals or not.

Dreadful, lazy, front-runner of a footballer

No question the environments Goodwin and Bailey walked into couldn't have been more different

Wow. Bails was a terrific bloke but on all available evidence that's an incredibly long bow to draw.

3 with Hibberd

Not not a huge fan of his but the footy department see him every day at training and are doing a pretty reasonable job so happy to back them in

How good has his kicking on both sides become in the last year or two. Almost the complete player now.

Never thought I'd see Jayden Hunt compared to Rohan Bail!

You've seriously got to be joking. You said that he never said he came back overweight. I point you to a direct quote where Pedersen says "I came back a little heavy". But it's me with a lack of comprehension skills?! You couldn't make it up. If Pedersen says he came back heavy, if the club says he came back heavy, if his teammates say he came back heavy, THEN HE CAME BACK HEAVY. It's OK to admit you're wrong once in a while.

"I had a shoulder reconstruction over the pre-season and came back a little bit heavy, so Simon Goodwin sat me down and said, ‘you want to put a jumper on for this club then get down to the weight you need to be at.’ He told me that the way I was at the time wasn’t going to help the team and that I was probably being a bad teammate". How could you possibly argue with that? It beggars belief.

You cannot seriously STILL be peddling this line? He admits he came back overweight. The club has said he came back overweight. Why on earth do you think you know better than the people directly involved?!

The word some people seem to be looking for is uninterested. Disinterested means impartial.

Mate have you watched him play at all in the past two seasons? He's an absolute shadow of his former self. He's about to turn 30 and is done.

Kieren Jack? Really? He can't get a game for them anymore. Would make no sense.

I'd say pick 14 for Mitchell was about right.