DubDee

This time last year it would have been T Mac but he has been inconsistent recently so Jetta gets the nod. Id back t Mac to come back into form though, no one tries harder

They'll look at mids especially that are tired or carrying knocks to take the week off. No way Newton should get dropped, played well, kicked a really important goal. We need to reward hard work and good performance

Viney by a street

The hogan one where he was outside 50 with watts in the square alone was unbelievable. Then hogan handballs it? i guess he somehow didn't see watts.

Terrific to see so many under 21 yo's getting votes and leading the club. 9 players with less than 20 games today

Who would you bring in?

We really have to bring in Dunn or O Mac and play them fwd/2nd ruck any other option? hogan and T Mac can help out around the ground in the ruck but not centre bounces

agree Garland is playing average footy. might be in over Dunn as he can play small and is a bit quicker. bears dont have too many talls

Salem is dropped as he has been performing well below his ability. Hasn't been many chase down tackles like last year. I support him being dropped. They showed faith in him by bringing him straight back in. I am liking the new standards.

Blown away by this bloke. What a pick by the recruiters, he was nowhere a year or two ago. Keep eating the nuggets on game day Clayton!

surprised most want a KFB and the least want a KPF. as far as trading in players, Id say KPF/2nd ruck is one of our biggest needs if not the biggest. Dawes, Pedo are not upto it. Weed and Hullett will not be impacting games this year or next at the least. they should play some games next year but they wont get us to finals Put Frost down back with Mac brothers and Dunn, Garland and draft a young defender We need a proper target up fwd to complement Hogan

thanks for the reply I just thought these guys retired based on future potential issues rather than having confirmed brain damage but I could well be wrong. 100% the priority is player health but I'm just shocked about the change in stance from 'she'll be right' to 'we better rest him for half the year' how is Selwood, bartel, out there playing for all these years, surely they would have had 10+ concussions. hopefully this mega cautious approach is not being driven by the threat of law suits if this was an epidemic, I havent seen much the evidence of players from the 70's 80's being diagnosed. i would hate to see players careers cut short based on an area that we have said is in its infancy research wise anyway, not trying to be controversial... just my general uneducated vibe on the issue.

this really is alarming if players are at risk of brain damage Does anyone know of players that have brain damage from footy (I think there was Bell?). I would have thought if the risk is as big as predicted there would be dozens of players especially from the 80's when they would beat hell of each other. Prior to this generation players would always play the next week and almost always keep playing in the same game, so hopefully we haven't seen an influx of affected players but I have not heard of any others by the way, I ain't no doctor and don't have a lot of medical knowledge on this topic, so excuse my ignorance if others do

I cannot believe he didnt get 2 weeks for that elbow - flush to the head. to say that wasnt intentional but Jettas was is ridicuous but then again, it was a Hawks player

knowing Roos, he would have pushed him to get the defensive side of game rock solid first. im expecting a big 2nd half of the year from this fella

he was great last year but this year he is at 52%. even Gawny is higher than that! Dead-eye Wattsy is at 73% which is remarkable

I have come to the conclusion the umpires decide year on year which rules to enforce. at the moment, incorrect disposal and throwing (unless blatently obvious) are not being paid as this lets the game move really frustrating the changes to the game are being driven by umpires

Surely Jetta doesn't get rubbed out for that? it wasn't intentional, more of a reflex with out backline in bits he would be a big out. he is turning into one of our most important players

38038 only 1,962 to go to the big 40K! we're a chance

http://www.melbournefc.com.au/news/2016-05-12/brayshaw-salem-available-for-selection M Jones has a back issue hence the soreness and the mystery aspect to the injury. AVB one week away. H still out Salem/Gus available

I am still scared from that game in round 20. First 12 goals kicked by the dogs. 12! the footy world is watching with lots of good press for the Dees thus week. Carn the farkin demons!!

From memory past no longer an issue but it was an issue last year asked about having the youngest list, was it by design. Said no in his roosey way. Basically said the younger guys are earning their spots over older lads says he doesn't do heaps of the technical side of coaching. Praised his assistants no end. Said he works with the leaders and makes sure mindset is correct, tries to drag each player out and chat has a house in Hawaii that he can rent out at a reasonable rate

touche!

I don't think we can keep saying we are a better team than St Kilda when they keep beating us I have thought we are far superior than them over the past 2 years but the evidence has finally convinced me they are slightly ahead of us right now. I am still very confident we have the better/younger list and will be much better than them very soon

I don't think a Ba-Zillion Dollar deal until the turn of the century is out of the question