DubDee

How do you know the club think we are better balanced and structured without him? Guessing? He will likely go home at some point so we are trying to get the best deal for him. Replace him like for like? That’s the whole point, there are no Jesse Hogan’s out there. He is a gun young player that imo opinion will dominate the comp over the next 5 years.

How the [censored] do the hawks keep bending over the comp?! Mitchell for 14, Scully for 40. Its like there is different rules for them

You beauty!!!

How can the hawks possibly get wingard and Scully? They only have pick 16 scully would be an end of first round pick?

Wouldn’t want to lose hunt. He value is very low atm and I expect him to bounce back hard.

JM and MFC should have no issue with keeping hogan for next year. His value will go up as I’d expect him to play a full season and kick 60+ goals. Hogan is a professional and us exploring options which is within his rights to do

So Scully wants to come home now? the little [censored]

Hogan allegedly telling Freo he wants to go there would make sense as to why Freo think they hold some power in negiotiations.

Burton called on holiday to be told he’ll be traded. Wtf. Probably their best young player. They ask loyalty and show none. All to get an inconsistent flakey player in wingard.

Alright alright Geeez! Misread a footy stats site. Apparebtly G stands for games not goals. ?

I’m happy about Wingard going to the hawks. So overrated. Never kicked more than 24 goals. Looks like a star a few times a year but is soft and lacks intensity. I heard he wants a million a year?!? And trade would be one or two first rounders? Madness!! Smacks of desperation by Clarko n Co

We have rejected the offer and are happy to keep him and deal with west coast next year. Jay clark tweet. Sorry can’t copy the link atm

GC wouldn’t want to Keep a want away ‘captain’ when they want to turn over a new leaf. They don’t have too much bargaining power. 5 is overs for sure

It was a hypothetical question. Feel free to answer it if you like

So you don’t think using pick 5 for May AND having pick 10 for another trade or using in the draft is a better outcome?? surely this notion isn’t too hard to understand

True. But if a gun like beams goes to the pies they will be a lot better next year

My brain tells me there ya no point checking this thread until Friday. But I’ll check every hour just to be safe

If we offer a bloke that’s played 8 games a 4 year deal that would be insane

And probably 29 the year after I’d imagine! ?

May is 26 yo

Freo are no doubt trying to negotate for something extra for Neale like a second rounder. good news is that every argument they use with Brisbane we can throw back in their face with Hogan

GC are in for possibly the worst few seasons of all time. list the players theyve lost over the ast 3 years and you have a bloody good side. theyll have picks 2-3-4 or whatever but it doesnt matter, they will just train them up for another team to poach. hard to see any hope for them

why is there still a rookie draft and rookie list? just add the rookies to the main list and clubs will take more picks in the national draft. no reason for rookies to be paid a 1/4 of someone drafted at pick 88. they do all the same work.

nah, no special process, I just meant a couple of blokes from casey we could put on our list, wuold need to be via the draft I guess although i'd be hopeful of using late picks

fair enough. I agree with all that - aside from trying Frost fwd again! ? not the end of the world in terms of our depth, but it is significant in terms of our high end talent