DubDee

If GWS lose Shiel this year and Kelly next that will be game over for them being a premiership threat in my opinion. they dont bring much talent in aside from draft picks. who wants to play in front of 8K. Bring it on. Kelly will rival Oliver in 2 years for the best player in the comp.

will miss yelling PEEEEDDDDDDOOOOOOO! put in some great efforts, especially when Gawn went down last year there will be quite a few list changes this year!

Gawny played 25 games at 85% gametime with little to no time resting fwd. He simply cannot continue t do this and expect to play for another 5+ years. Welcome Braydon, think I'll call him Pruesssy

What a ridiculous thread. Hogan is one of key pillars to build on for the future. In the first half of the season he was arguably our best player and certainly in the top 3. Ran all day, averaged over 3 goals a game, played deep mid, a nightmare to match up on. in 2-3 years I think he will be the best fwd in the game kicking 60+ a year when he matures a bit more, learns to use his body better and get into space he loves the club and wants to stay not on the trade table.

If these are his numbers with two bad shoulders, he should be in for a decent year next year! Disposals - 734 * Contested - 404 * Clearances - 161 * Tackles - 168 * Goals - 12 Assists - 18 Inside 50s - 111 * club leader. he was second for the club in inside 50s

Mitchell wins as there is no one to take votes off him at the hawks. If he stayed at the swans no way he would have won. Gus is a fricken gun!

Pies are like the Tigers: not great but their best players are in their prime and are experienced. Sidebottom, Pendlebury, Treloar, Howe, Adams. When our best players (Gus, Clarry, Hogan, Trac) are 25+ we will be a very good side. expect some up and down seasons until then

Brayshaw in our best? Surely I watched I different game. A young bloke choked on a big occasion. He will learn from it. He had a terrible first half and couldn’t catch a cold. Kept trying. Fair play

Massive choke game over

Can’t see us winning this one. Not sure if it’s just nerves or what.

Big call but I reckon this is a season defining game. ?

Pies are playing great footy. 8 contested marks from Cox. No way to stop him.

Dees v Pies GF first time both teams missed finals the 4 previous years?

Far out BT can’t even commentate a set shot at goal. He missed. Oh no he didn’t. You don’t have to predict it mate

Apologies, I meant no offense. I was just trying to differentiate between attending members and the 3 game/pet membership types. But there are a few inbetween as you point out

nice work Jim, they said it couldn't be done but finally someone has referenced Charles Dickens on DL!

Astbury a chance to miss. he has been quarentined with illness may all 44 players contract the virus! ?

interesting stats. less than half of members are what I would call 'real members' - ie that go to games and live in melbourne no wonder the numbers go through the roof each year and don't reflect attendences

going to be a rugby scrum of a game. if pies keep the intensity up all game, 60 points could win it.

It’s hard to predict though, if Smith plays very well I don’t think he’d be dropped for the GF.

in fairness the OP must be written by a kid. pooh pooh? really?

I'd expect Maynard and Adams etc to really rough up the tigers. Probably the only chance collingwood have. on talent and structure, the tigers should win easily.

ha no worries! i was trying to do the maths of 3 under 3 - technically possible but not to be advised!

why is he going to the Saints?? must be on a golden ticket and reckons his body is shot. you would think he would go to a side with a chance of finals

3 under 3? good lord. you deserve a quiet beer mate!