DubDee

Hibberd certainly deserves it. Great experience down back and can lock down a fwd really well. Melksham is tough. Such a tease. That game against the blues and then some average game. I’d personally let him go. Just doesn’t have the consistency

Can someone direct me to the laughing at Essendon page??

Who gives a rats about points. You do the deals to get the players and picks you want. 27 gets us the second best ruck in the game. Fantastic deal coupled with the Pies paying some wages and him taking a pay cut

lol Logue on 800K. worth about half that. I guess North have to pay someone to get to 90% cap

can't see the eagles getting out of the bottom 6. Lose Kennedy and Rioli etc. So F1 would be great

I'm sure if Harmes chose to leave to get the most of himself and play midfield, his teammates would support him and it wouldn't damage our culture. We are clearly not pushing him out based on what Lamb said

So this sounds like a done deal. which you would think means the draft pick has been agreed upon. what could the deal be? we only have 32 which wouldn't be enough. maybe Future 2nd rounder plus 32? F2 would be around 34 i guess F2 and 32 with a Pies pick coming back our way?

Hasn’t finished in the top 10 in the BnF in the past 3 years.

Pick 13 and around 14 is not enough. GAGF Freo

If Harmes played 22 games as an accountable mid it would mean we rate him as such. But we don’t. 4 years later he has been dropped several times. Since 2018 he hasn’t put a consistent season together keep digging mate

Harmes and Hunt are as good as Angus? Lol call me when either comes third in the Brownlow

Is this sarcasm? Getting rid of average players and keeping quality players. Good strategy no?

I’m hearing Dodoro is happy to let pick 60 go to us if we add a second round pick

Everyone wants to bring in a gun through trade but not happy to lose a top 25 player.

I don’t mind this. If we want picks and capital for a trade we need to give up good players but not core first 18 guys. Harmes is great and it might be a win win as he could be a regular midfielder at another club would want something decent in return

How many years did he get? How we know the comp but not the contract?

Agree they are not comparable but not in the way you mean 6"2' proven gun mid, BnF winner, 15 votes in the Brownlow last year. Future leader, can go fwd and kick goals. LJ's worth is largely on what he might become due to his physical attributes (and playing some great games for us)

Oh right, I didn’t realise. I watched him play once and he was marking everything but ended up with 5 behinds or something similar. Knows how to find the ball for sure

Graham Wright said today the deal with MFC Was a fair way down the track

Pies are getting rid of a promising key fwd to the Cats in Henry and an AA ruck to us while paying part of the salary They are bringing in Frampton and McStay. List better? Hell no

we might get pick 40 for Bedford. then package 32 and 40 to a club for pick ~24. send 24 to Pies

or he can keep his source to himself and keep providing information. He has some form from the past and gets some inside info. if you don't want to read it either ignore him or block him but others like me want to hear it

+ Kruezer and Gibbs.

to make it worse, this time last year JHF would have been telling North he wants to go to them and will be loyal. unless his attitude changes, he won't make it as a quality AFL player. buyer beware

Tigers going the Geelong model. 2 great players, will have them in top 4 contention next year